A keystone species is one whose removal would cause significant changes to the community structure despite the species not necessarily being the most abundant. Which of the following best illustrates the concept of a keystone species?
- AA decomposer that breaks down dead organic matter and recycles nutrients at the base of the food web
- BA dominant tree species that makes up 80% of the forest biomass and shapes the habitat through sheer abundance
- CAn invasive species that outcompetes native organisms for resources and reduces native population sizes
- DA top predator whose removal triggers a trophic cascade that reduces community diversityCorrect
Why D is right
A keystone species has a disproportionately large effect on community structure relative to its abundance. Classic examples include top predators (like sea otters or wolves) whose removal triggers trophic cascades that restructure the entire community, reducing biodiversity and simplifying the food web.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while decomposers play important roles in nutrient recycling, the keystone species concept emphasizes disproportionate impact relative to abundance; decomposers are generally numerous and their role is proportional to their numbers.
- B
- Incorrect because a species that makes up 80% of biomass is influential due to its abundance, which describes a dominant species rather than a keystone species.
- C
- Incorrect because an invasive species disrupts the community but is not a keystone species; its presence, not its removal, causes the significant change.
Sea otters in the Pacific Northwest prey heavily on sea urchins, which are voracious grazers of kelp forests. When sea otter populations decline due to orca predation, sea urchin populations explode and kelp forests are reduced to "urchin barrens." Which prediction is best supported by this four-level trophic cascade?
- AIncreasing orca populations would indirectly increase kelp forest density
- BIncreasing orca populations would indirectly decrease kelp forest densityCorrect
- CSea urchin populations are regulated primarily by bottom-up nutrient availability
- DRemoving orcas from the system would have no measurable effect on kelp forest density
Why B is right
In this four-level trophic cascade (orcas -> otters -> urchins -> kelp), increasing orca populations would reduce sea otter numbers, releasing sea urchins from predation pressure. More urchins would consume more kelp, decreasing kelp forest density. Each trophic level has an alternating positive/negative indirect effect on levels below it.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because this reverses the direction of the indirect effect. More orcas means fewer otters, which means more urchins and less kelp, not more kelp.
- C
- Incorrect because the scenario demonstrates top-down control of urchin populations by otter predation, not bottom-up regulation by nutrient supply.
- D
- Incorrect because the trophic cascade model explicitly predicts that changes at any level propagate through the food web; removing orcas would release otters, which would suppress urchins and benefit kelp.