The committee's final report, [which it submitted to the board last Tuesday], recommended sweeping changes to the hiring process. Which choice best punctuates the underlined portion?
- A— which it submitted to the board last Tuesday —
- B, which it submitted to the board last Tuesday,Correct
- Cwhich it submitted to the board last Tuesday
- Dwhich it submitted to the board last Tuesday,
Why B is right
The clause 'which it submitted to the board last Tuesday' is nonrestrictive — it adds extra information about the report but is not needed to identify which report. Nonrestrictive clauses introduced by 'which' must be set off by commas on both sides.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because dashes can set off nonrestrictive elements but are typically reserved for added emphasis; commas are the standard punctuation for a 'which' nonrestrictive clause.
- C
- Incorrect because no commas are used at all, making the nonrestrictive clause appear restrictive.
- D
- Incorrect because only one comma is used, leaving the clause open at the start without a comma after 'report.'
The city's water supply[, which serves over two million residents,] must meet strict federal safety standards at all times. The underlined clause is:
- Aa nonrestrictive clause correctly set off with commasCorrect
- Ban independent clause incorrectly joined with commas
- Ca restrictive clause that should not be set off with commas
- Da nonrestrictive clause that should use dashes instead of commas
Why A is right
The clause 'which serves over two million residents' adds extra information about the city's water supply but does not restrict or identify which supply is meant. Nonrestrictive 'which' clauses are correctly set off with commas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the clause is not an independent clause — it is a dependent relative clause with no independent finite verb.
- C
- Incorrect because the clause does not define or restrict which water supply is referenced — the subject is already specific.
- D
- Incorrect because while dashes can set off nonrestrictive elements, there is no reason to deviate from standard comma usage here.
The museum's new exhibit on the Space Age features artifacts [from the Apollo missions, several of which had never been publicly displayed before]. Which best describes the underlined relative clause?
- Aa clause that should use 'that' instead of 'which'
- Ba clause that creates a dangling modifier
- Ca restrictive clause that should not be set off with a comma
- Da nonrestrictive clause correctly preceded by a commaCorrect
Why D is right
'Several of which had never been publicly displayed before' is a nonrestrictive relative clause adding supplementary information about the artifacts. It is correctly preceded by a comma, and 'which' is the correct pronoun for things.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because 'that' is used in restrictive clauses; since this is nonrestrictive, 'which' is correct.
- B
- Incorrect because relative clauses modifying nouns are not dangling modifiers.
- C
- Incorrect because the clause does not restrict which artifacts are meant — it adds extra information about some of them.