The hikers packed their gear carefully, making sure to bring extra water, sunscreen, and a detailed map of the trail.
Which of the following correctly uses commas in the sentence above?
- AThe hikers packed their gear carefully, making sure to bring extra water, sunscreen, and a detailed map of the trail.Correct
- BThe hikers packed their gear carefully, making sure to bring extra water sunscreen and a detailed map of the trail.
- CThe hikers packed their gear, carefully, making sure to bring extra water, sunscreen, and a detailed map of the trail.
- DThe hikers packed their gear carefully making sure to bring extra water, sunscreen, and a detailed map of the trail.
Why A is right
The original sentence correctly uses a comma after 'carefully' to set off the participial phrase 'making sure to bring...' and uses commas to separate the three items in the series (water, sunscreen, and a detailed map).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because items in a series must be separated by commas; omitting commas between 'water,' 'sunscreen,' and 'a detailed map' creates ambiguity.
- C
- Incorrect because placing a comma around 'carefully' incorrectly treats it as a nonrestrictive element, disrupting the flow of the sentence.
- D
- Incorrect because the participial phrase 'making sure to bring extra water...' is an introductory modifier that requires a comma after 'carefully' to separate it properly.
Running toward the finish line, [the crowd cheered loudly/the runner's legs burned/the medal gleamed in the distance/the race was nearly over].
Which choice avoids a dangling modifier?
- Athe runner's legs burnedCorrect
- Bthe medal gleamed in the distance
- Cthe race was nearly over
- Dthe crowd cheered loudly
Why A is right
'Running toward the finish line' is a participial phrase that must modify the subject of the main clause. Only 'the runner's legs burned' makes the runner (implied by 'the runner's legs') the logical subject performing the running action.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because it implies the medal was running toward the finish line, which is illogical and constitutes a dangling modifier.
- C
- Incorrect because 'the race' cannot be running toward the finish line; this creates a dangling modifier.
- D
- Incorrect because it implies the crowd was running toward the finish line, which is a dangling modifier — the crowd is not the one running.
Tired after a long day of hiking, [the cabin looked inviting/the hikers found the cabin inviting/the cabin was inviting to the hikers/a warm fire was burning in the cabin].
Which option avoids a dangling modifier?
- Aa warm fire was burning in the cabin
- Bthe hikers found the cabin invitingCorrect
- Cthe cabin was inviting to the hikers
- Dthe cabin looked inviting
Why B is right
The participial phrase 'Tired after a long day of hiking' modifies the subject of the main clause. Only humans can be tired from hiking, so the subject must be 'the hikers.' Option B correctly places 'the hikers' as the subject.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because 'a warm fire' cannot be tired from hiking; this is also a dangling modifier.
- C
- Incorrect because 'the cabin' is still the grammatical subject, creating a dangling modifier since the cabin cannot be tired.
- D
- Incorrect because it implies the cabin was tired after hiking, which is a dangling modifier.