Skip to content
ACT · English

Nonrestrictive clause

Nonrestrictive clause appears in 22 reviewed ACT questions and sits in English. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Nonrestrictive clause is tested

Example 1Medium
The student earned a scholarship, [she/who/which/and she] had maintained a perfect GPA throughout high school. Which option creates a grammatically correct sentence?
  1. Awho
  2. Bshe
  3. Cwhich
  4. Dand sheCorrect

Why D is right

The stem asks which option creates a grammatically correct sentence. 'And she had maintained a perfect GPA throughout high school' joins two independent clauses with a comma plus the coordinating conjunction 'and,' producing a correct compound sentence. Choice A ('who') is flawed: placed immediately after 'a scholarship,' the relative clause attaches to the nearest noun 'scholarship' rather than to 'student,' a misplaced relative clause. Choice B ('she') creates a comma splice. Choice C ('which') wrongly uses a thing-pronoun for a person. Only D is grammatically correct.
Why the other 2 choices miss
B
Incorrect because 'she had maintained a perfect GPA' would create a comma splice — two independent clauses joined with only a comma.
C
Incorrect because 'which' refers to things, not people; the student is a person, so 'who' is correct.
Example 2Medium
The merger between the two corporations[,] which was announced last Tuesday[,] is expected to be completed by year's end. Are the commas around 'which was announced last Tuesday' used correctly?
  1. AYes; commas correctly set off this nonrestrictive relative clause.Correct
  2. BNo; 'that' should replace 'which,' and commas should be removed.
  3. CNo; only one comma is needed, before 'which.'
  4. DNo; 'which' clauses never require commas.

Why A is right

The relative clause 'which was announced last Tuesday' is nonrestrictive — it provides additional information but is not essential to identifying which merger is being discussed (there is only one). Nonrestrictive clauses are correctly set off by commas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because 'that' is used for restrictive clauses (no commas); this clause is nonrestrictive and properly uses 'which' with commas.
C
Incorrect because nonrestrictive clauses require commas both before and after the clause (not just before).
D
Incorrect because 'which' clauses that are nonrestrictive (providing extra, non-essential information) do require commas.
Example 3Medium
The film's climactic scene[,] in which the two rivals finally confront each other face to face[,] was filmed over the course of three exhausting days. Are the commas around the relative clause correct?
  1. ANo; 'that' should replace 'which' and the commas should be removed.
  2. BYes; the nonrestrictive relative clause is correctly set off by commas.Correct
  3. CNo; parentheses should be used instead of commas.
  4. DNo; semicolons should replace the commas.

Why B is right

The relative clause 'in which the two rivals finally confront each other face to face' is nonrestrictive — it provides additional information about the scene but is not essential to identifying it. Nonrestrictive clauses are correctly set off by commas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because nonrestrictive clauses use 'which' with commas, not 'that' without commas; 'that' would indicate a restrictive clause.
C
Incorrect because while parentheses could be used, the commas are not wrong; both are acceptable for nonrestrictive modifiers.
D
Incorrect because semicolons cannot be used to set off a clause within a sentence; they join independent clauses.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from English.