The novelist's most celebrated work[, a sweeping saga of three generations of a Mexican American family,] won the National Book Award in 1998. Which describes the underlined phrase?
- Aa restrictive appositive that should not be set off with commas
- Ba nonrestrictive appositive correctly set off with commasCorrect
- Ca relative clause that should begin with 'which'
- Da dangling modifier that needs revision
Why B is right
The appositive 'a sweeping saga of three generations of a Mexican American family' renames 'the novelist's most celebrated work' — a noun already fully identified. It adds descriptive information but does not restrict meaning. It is correctly set off with commas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the appositive is nonrestrictive; the work is already specified as the 'most celebrated,' so the description is supplementary.
- C
- Incorrect because the phrase is a noun phrase (appositive), not a relative clause — it has no relative pronoun or finite verb.
- D
- Incorrect because the phrase directly follows and describes the noun it renames; it is not a dangling modifier.
The athlete, [exhausted from the ten-mile run], still managed to complete the final obstacle course with impressive speed. The underlined phrase is:
- Aa dangling modifier that must be revised
- Ban absolute phrase incorrectly using commas
- Ca restrictive modifier that should not use commas
- Da nonrestrictive participial phrase correctly set off with commasCorrect
Why D is right
'Exhausted from the ten-mile run' is a participial phrase modifying 'the athlete.' Since the athlete is already specified, the phrase adds supplementary (nonrestrictive) information and is correctly set off by commas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the phrase directly follows and modifies 'the athlete,' who is clearly the one exhausted — there is no dangling modifier.
- B
- Incorrect because an absolute phrase contains a noun + participial phrase ('his legs aching'); this phrase has only an adjective + prepositional phrase ('exhausted from...'), making it a participial phrase, not an absolute phrase.
- C
- Incorrect because the phrase does not restrict which athlete is meant — it provides additional descriptive information.
The professor's new book[, drawing on fifteen years of field research,] challenges long-held assumptions about migratory bird patterns. The underlined phrase is:
- Aa restrictive modifier that should be written without commas
- Ban absolute phrase incorrectly punctuated
- Ca nonrestrictive participial phrase correctly set off with commasCorrect
- Da dangling modifier that needs revision
Why C is right
'Drawing on fifteen years of field research' is a participial phrase modifying 'the professor's new book.' Since the book is already specifically identified, the phrase adds supplementary nonrestrictive information and is correctly set off with commas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the phrase does not restrict which book is meant — the book is already identified as 'the professor's new book.'
- B
- Incorrect because an absolute phrase has the structure 'noun + participle' ('the research completed'); this phrase has only a participial phrase without a separate noun.
- D
- Incorrect because the phrase logically refers to the book (which is the product of the research); while a book cannot literally 'draw on research,' this is an accepted figurative construction in academic writing.