The novelist, [a recipient of numerous awards/who has won many awards/an award winner of renown/recognized for her literary achievements], published her tenth book this year.
Which option is most concise while providing specific information?
- Aa recipient of numerous awardsCorrect
- Bwho has won many awards
- Crecognized for her literary achievements
- Dan award winner of renown
Why A is right
'A recipient of numerous awards' is a concise appositive noun phrase that efficiently provides the relevant information. It is shorter and more direct than the relative clause in option B and more specific than options C and D.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because 'who has won many awards' is a relative clause that is slightly longer than the appositive phrase 'a recipient of numerous awards.'
- C
- Incorrect because 'recognized for her literary achievements' is vaguer than specifying she has received numerous awards.
- D
- Incorrect because 'an award winner of renown' is vague — 'of renown' adds little specific meaning beyond saying she is well-known.
The abandoned warehouse on Elm Street, once the heart of the city's textile industry[,] now serves as an art gallery and community center.
Is a comma needed after 'industry'?
- ANo, because the appositive phrase before it is restrictive.
- BYes, because the phrase 'once the heart of the city's textile industry' is a nonrestrictive appositive that must be set off by commas.Correct
- CYes, because a comma is required before every use of 'now.'
- DNo, because commas are not used after appositives.
Why B is right
The phrase 'once the heart of the city's textile industry' is a nonrestrictive appositive providing additional information about the warehouse. Nonrestrictive appositives are set off by commas. Since a comma opens the phrase (after 'Elm Street'), a closing comma after 'industry' is also required.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because a restrictive appositive would be essential to identifying the warehouse; since the warehouse is already identified by its location, this phrase is nonrestrictive and requires commas.
- C
- Incorrect because the comma is needed because of the nonrestrictive appositive structure, not because of the word 'now.'
- D
- Incorrect because nonrestrictive appositives do require commas to set them off from the rest of the sentence.
The concert tickets sold out within minutes[—]a testament to the band's enormous popularity.
Is the dash used correctly here?
- AYes; the dash correctly introduces a brief, emphatic summary statement.Correct
- BNo; a comma should be used instead of a dash.
- CNo; a colon should introduce this explanatory appositive.
- DNo; the appositive requires commas on both sides.
Why A is right
A dash can effectively introduce a concluding explanatory phrase or appositive at the end of a sentence. Here, 'a testament to the band's enormous popularity' is a dramatic, emphatic summary of the preceding information, and the dash is correctly used.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because while a comma would be grammatically acceptable, the dash is also correct and adds appropriate emphasis to the concluding phrase.
- C
- Incorrect because while a colon could work here, the dash is equally correct and is typically used for more dramatic or emphatic effects than a colon.
- D
- Incorrect because appositives at the end of a sentence require only one dash (or comma) before them, not two.