Skip to content
SAT · Problem Solving and Data Analysis

Without replacement

Without replacement appears in 5 reviewed SAT questions and sits in Problem Solving and Data Analysis. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Without replacement is tested

Example 1Harder
In a bag, there are 8 red marbles and 12 blue marbles. If 4 marbles are drawn without replacement, what is the approximate probability that all 4 are red?
  1. A0.050
  2. B0.014Correct
  3. C0.026
  4. D0.005

Why B is right

Draw without replacement, so each draw reduces both the favorable and total counts. P(all 4 red) = (8/20) × (7/19) × (6/18) × (5/17) = (8×7×6×5)/(20×19×18×17) = 1680/116280 ≈ 0.0144. Equivalently, P = C(8,4)/C(20,4) = 70/4845 ≈ 0.0144. Rounded, this is approximately 0.014, choice B.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
0.050 = 1/20 treats the event as a single uniform draw, ignoring that 4 specific marbles must all be red.
C
0.026 comes from (8/20)^4 = 0.4^4 ≈ 0.0256, which incorrectly assumes drawing WITH replacement.
D
0.005 underestimates the probability, e.g. by over-shrinking the numerator or using wrong counts in the sequential product.
Example 2Medium
A bag has 5 yellow, 3 green, and 2 orange candies. If two candies are drawn randomly without replacement, what is the probability that both are yellow?
  1. A1/9
  2. B1/4
  3. C2/9Correct
  4. D4/9

Why C is right

The bag holds 5 + 3 + 2 = 10 candies, 5 of them yellow. The first draw is yellow with probability 5/10. Because that candy is not put back, the bag then holds 9 candies, 4 of them yellow, so the second draw is yellow with probability 4/9. Multiply the two: P(both yellow) = (5/10) × (4/9) = 20/90 = 2/9, which is choice C.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
1/9 = 10/90 mixes two ways of counting. It takes the 10 unordered pairs of yellow candies, C(5,2), and divides by the 90 ordered draws (10 × 9) when it should divide by the 45 unordered pairs, which gives 10/45 = 2/9.
B
1/4 = (5/10) × (5/10) treats the draws as if the first candy were put back, so the second draw still has 5 yellow candies out of 10.
D
4/9 is only the chance that the second candy is yellow once the first was yellow. It leaves out the 5/10 chance that the first candy is yellow.
Example 3Harder
A jar contains 4 red, 6 blue, and 2 yellow candies. If two candies are drawn one at a time without replacement, what is the probability that both are blue?
  1. A5/22Correct
  2. B36/144
  3. C1/2
  4. D3/11

Why A is right

There are 4 + 6 + 2 = 12 candies, 6 of them blue. The first draw is blue with probability 6/12. That candy is not replaced, so 5 blue candies remain among 11, and the second draw is blue with probability 5/11. Multiply the two: P(both blue) = (6/12)(5/11) = 30/132 = 5/22.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
36/144 = (6/12)(6/12) treats the draws as if the first candy were put back, so the blue count and the total never drop for the second draw.
C
1/2 = 6/12 is only the chance that the first candy is blue. It never multiplies by the chance that the second candy is also blue.
D
3/11 = (6/12)(6/11) lowers the total to 11 for the second draw but forgets that one blue candy is gone, so it uses 6 blue instead of 5.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Problem Solving and Data Analysis.