The following text is original practice text. Both the spoken word and the written symbol ________ from an underlying system of mental representations, according to the theoretical framework proposed by Chomsky in the 1950s.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
- Ais deriving
- BderiveCorrect
- Chas derived
- Dderives
Why B is right
The subject of the sentence is a compound subject: "Both the spoken word and the written symbol." A compound subject joined by "and" is plural, requiring a plural verb. "Derive" is the plural present-tense form that correctly agrees with this compound plural subject. The correlative conjunction "both...and" confirms the plural nature of the subject.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because "is deriving" is a singular progressive form. It disagrees with the plural compound subject, and the progressive aspect implies an ongoing, in-progress action rather than the general or habitual truth expressed in a theoretical claim.
- C
- Incorrect because "has derived" is a singular present-perfect form. It disagrees with the plural compound subject, and the present perfect implies a recently completed action with present relevance, which is not the appropriate sense for describing a general theoretical principle.
- D
- Incorrect because "derives" is a singular verb form. Although "the spoken word" and "the written symbol" are each singular on their own, they are joined by "both...and," making the compound subject plural and requiring the plural verb "derive."