Skip to content
PSAT/NMSQT · Standard English Conventions

That vs which

That vs which appears in 8 reviewed PSAT/NMSQT questions and sits in Standard English Conventions. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How That vs which is tested

Example 1Easier
The following text is original practice text. The painting ______ Michelangelo completed for the Sistine Chapel took four years of grueling labor to finish. Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
  1. Awhich
  2. BthatCorrect
  3. Cwhom
  4. Dwho

Why B is right

'That' is the correct relative pronoun for things (paintings) in a restrictive relative clause. 'The painting that Michelangelo completed for the Sistine Chapel' identifies which specific painting is being discussed. 'That' is standard for things in a restrictive clause.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because while 'which' can refer to things, it typically introduces non-restrictive clauses. Here, the clause is restrictive (identifying a specific painting), so 'that' is preferred.
C
Incorrect because 'whom' is an object pronoun for people; it cannot refer to a painting.
D
Incorrect because 'who' refers to people; a painting is a thing.
Example 2Medium
The following text is original practice text. The guidance counselor told Marcus ______ he should begin working on college application essays the summer before his senior year. Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
  1. AthatCorrect
  2. Bwhich
  3. C, which
  4. D, that

Why A is right

'That' correctly introduces the indirect speech clause ('that he should begin working...'). No comma is needed before 'that' when it introduces an embedded noun clause after a verb like 'told.' The construction 'told Marcus that...' is standard.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because 'which' introduces relative clauses modifying nouns; it cannot introduce an indirect speech noun clause after 'told Marcus.'
C
Incorrect because 'which' is not appropriate for indirect speech, and the comma would create additional confusion.
D
Incorrect because a comma before 'that' in an indirect speech construction ('told Marcus, that he should...') is not standard; commas are not placed before 'that' in embedded noun clauses.
Example 3Medium
The following text is original practice text. The glacier, ______ has been retreating for decades, lost a record amount of ice during the hottest summer on record. Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
  1. Awho
  2. Bit
  3. CwhichCorrect
  4. Dthat

Why C is right

'Which' is the correct relative pronoun for things (a glacier) in a non-restrictive relative clause set off by commas. The clause 'which has been retreating for decades' provides additional, non-essential information about the glacier.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because 'who' refers to people or animals with personal characteristics; a glacier is a geographic feature.
B
Incorrect because 'it' is a personal pronoun, not a relative pronoun; using 'it' creates a comma splice rather than a relative clause.
D
Incorrect because 'that' introduces restrictive clauses and cannot be used in a non-restrictive clause set off by commas.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Standard English Conventions.