Skip to content
PSAT/NMSQT · Information and Ideas

Supporting evidence

Supporting evidence appears in 4 reviewed PSAT/NMSQT questions and sits in Information and Ideas. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Supporting evidence is tested

Example 1Harder
The following text is original practice text. Text: "Economists David Card and Alan Krueger challenged the conventional view that raising the minimum wage automatically increases unemployment. Their 1994 study compared employment at fast-food restaurants in New Jersey, which raised its minimum wage, with those in neighboring Pennsylvania, which did not. Rather than declining, employment at New Jersey restaurants held steady or increased slightly relative to Pennsylvania. The study prompted decades of further research and remains a landmark in labor economics." Which finding, if true, would most directly support the researchers' conclusion?
  1. ACard and Krueger's methodology was later adopted by researchers studying the effects of wage policy in European countries.
  2. BEmployment at fast-food chains in other states that raised minimum wages during the same period also remained stable or grew.Correct
  3. CPennsylvania fast-food restaurants experienced a slight decline in employment during the same period that New Jersey's employment held steady.
  4. DFast-food restaurant owners in New Jersey reported that they raised menu prices to offset higher labor costs after the wage increase.

Why B is right

Card and Krueger's conclusion was that raising the minimum wage does not necessarily cause employment to fall. Finding that other states also saw stable or growing employment after wage increases would directly support this conclusion by providing additional confirming evidence (Choice B). Choice A is about another team adopting the methodology, which does not validate the conclusion itself. Choice C would complicate the comparison, since a Pennsylvania decline could stem from unrelated factors and does not straightforwardly confirm the conclusion about New Jersey. Choice D concerns menu-price increases (cost pass-through), a different economic effect rather than the employment conclusion.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the adoption of a methodology by other researchers does not validate the conclusion drawn by the original study.
C
Incorrect because if Pennsylvania employment declined on its own, it complicates the comparison and does not straightforwardly support Card and Krueger's conclusion about New Jersey.
D
Incorrect because price increases speak to a different economic effect (cost pass-through) rather than directly supporting the employment conclusion.
Example 2Harder
The following text is original practice text. Text: "In 2015, the LIGO detectors recorded the first direct observation of gravitational waves — ripples in spacetime produced when two massive black holes merged 1.3 billion light-years away. Albert Einstein had predicted gravitational waves in 1916 as a consequence of his general theory of relativity, but scientists lacked instruments sensitive enough to detect them for nearly a century. The LIGO discovery opened what astronomers call a new 'window' on the universe, making it possible to detect cosmic events that produce no light." Which finding, if true, would most directly support the claim that gravitational wave detection opens a new window on the universe?
  1. AThe LIGO collaboration included physicists from more than 80 countries who contributed to the design of its detectors.
  2. BEinstein's original 1916 calculations contained minor mathematical errors that were corrected by later physicists.
  3. CThe 2015 detection required LIGO to measure a distance change smaller than one-thousandth the diameter of a proton.
  4. DGravitational wave observatories have since detected neutron star mergers that were invisible to optical telescopes.Correct

Why D is right

The claim is that gravitational wave detection lets scientists observe cosmic events that produce no light. Choice D states that gravitational wave observatories detected neutron star mergers that were invisible to optical telescopes, which directly supports the 'new window' claim. Choice A concerns the size of the collaboration, not detecting invisible events. Choice B concerns the accuracy of Einstein's original math. Choice C describes the detector's sensitivity, which is impressive context but does not show that gravitational waves reveal events undetectable by light-based telescopes.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the number of contributing countries speaks to the scale of collaboration, not to detecting events invisible to optical instruments.
B
Incorrect because the accuracy of Einstein's original calculations does not bear on whether gravitational wave detectors reveal previously invisible events.
C
Incorrect because detector sensitivity is impressive context, but it does not directly illustrate that gravitational waves reveal events undetectable by light-based telescopes.
Example 3Harder
The following text is original practice text. Text: "When you learn something new, your brain initially stores the memory in a fragile form in the hippocampus. During sleep, especially during slow-wave sleep, the brain replays these memories and gradually transfers them to the neocortex for long-term storage — a process called consolidation. Studies show that people who sleep after learning new information retain significantly more than those who remain awake. Even brief naps taken shortly after learning can improve recall, suggesting that the consolidation process begins quickly." Which finding, if true, would most directly support the claim that sleep plays an active role in memory consolidation rather than simply allowing rest?
  1. ABrain imaging shows that neural patterns from a learning task reactivate during slow-wave sleep, mirroring the original activity.Correct
  2. BPeople who consume caffeine before sleep have more fragmented slow-wave sleep and also report more difficulty remembering new vocabulary words.
  3. CStudents who study with flashcards before bed perform better on tests than students who study by rereading their notes.
  4. DParticipants in a sleep study reported feeling more mentally alert after a full night of sleep than after sleeping only four hours.

Why A is right

The text claims consolidation involves active memory replay during sleep (not just rest). Brain imaging showing that learning-related neural patterns reactivate during slow-wave sleep would directly confirm the active, replay-based mechanism. Choice B provides indirect correlation but is less direct than neurological evidence of active replay. Choice C is about study method, not the role of sleep. Choice D is about alertness, which reflects rest rather than active consolidation.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because this finding provides correlational support but does not directly demonstrate the active replay mechanism that distinguishes consolidation from mere rest.
C
Incorrect because this compares study techniques rather than demonstrating the active role of sleep in memory processing.
D
Incorrect because alertness after sleep is about rest, not about active memory consolidation processes during sleep.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Information and Ideas.