The following two texts present contrasting perspectives on the topic.
Text 1
Social media platforms create the illusion of connection while actually deepening loneliness. When people substitute scrolling through curated highlights of others' lives for genuine in-person interaction, they lose the messy, reciprocal quality that makes relationships meaningful. Surveys consistently show that heavy social media users report lower life satisfaction than those who use it sparingly.
Text 2
Critics of social media often overlook its equalizing potential. For people with disabilities, social anxiety, or rural isolation, online communities may be the only accessible form of peer connection. Dismissing digital relationships as inherently inferior ignores the real social needs these platforms meet for millions.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the sociologist's claim in Text 1 that social media deepens loneliness?
- ABy pointing out that the claim overlooks groups for whom online connection is more accessible than in-person interactionCorrect
- BBy arguing that social media companies should be required to redesign their platforms to promote genuine, reciprocal interaction
- CBy suggesting that self-reported survey data on life satisfaction are unreliable measures of whether people feel socially connected
- DBy agreeing that loneliness is widespread but arguing that social media is not the primary cause
Why A is right
Text 2 directly argues that critics overlook people — those with disabilities, social anxiety, or rural isolation — for whom online communities fill a real need. This is the author's direct counter to the claim that social media deepens loneliness.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because Text 2 makes no policy recommendations about platform design.
- C
- Incorrect because Text 2 never questions the reliability of self-reported surveys; it simply raises a counterexample the sociologist did not consider.
- D
- Incorrect because Text 2 does not discuss the causes of loneliness; it challenges the assumption that digital relationships are inferior.
The following two texts present contrasting perspectives on the topic.
Text 1
Controlled burns are one of the most effective tools for preventing catastrophic wildfires. By clearing dry undergrowth before it accumulates to dangerous levels, land managers can reduce the fuel available to large fires. Indigenous communities in North America practiced prescribed burning for thousands of years, maintaining healthy, fire-resistant landscapes long before European settlement disrupted these traditions.
Text 2
Controlled burns carry real risks that advocates sometimes minimize. Smoke from prescribed fires worsens air quality in nearby communities, disproportionately affecting people with asthma and other respiratory conditions. Without careful planning and monitoring, burns can escape control and damage the very ecosystems they are meant to protect.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the ecologist's claim in Text 1 that controlled burns are "one of the most effective tools" for preventing wildfires?
- ABy claiming that large wildfires are not actually caused by accumulated undergrowth
- BBy arguing that Indigenous burning traditions are too outdated to apply to modern forests
- CBy acknowledging the technique's potential but emphasizing that its benefits must be weighed against health and safety risksCorrect
- DBy agreeing completely and urging land managers to expand their use of prescribed burning immediately
Why C is right
Text 2 does not deny that controlled burns can prevent wildfires, but it highlights significant risks — air quality/respiratory harm and escaped fires — that must be considered. This is a qualified acknowledgment, matching C.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Text 2 does not challenge the underlying cause of wildfires; it questions the safety of the proposed solution.
- B
- Incorrect because Text 2 does not mention Indigenous traditions at all; it focuses on practical risks.
- D
- Incorrect because Text 2 raises serious concerns; its author would not agree completely or urge immediate expansion.
The following two texts present contrasting perspectives on the topic.
Text 1
Standardized tests, despite their well-documented limitations, provide one of the few consistent, comparable measures of student learning across schools and districts. Without such benchmarks, it becomes nearly impossible to identify achievement gaps or track whether interventions are working at a systemic level. The problem is not measurement itself but the overuse of tests as a proxy for teacher quality.
Text 2
No single exam can capture what a student knows, and the time spent preparing for standardized tests crowds out richer learning experiences — projects, discussions, creative writing. Tests measure what is easy to measure, not what is most important. A student who struggles to write a paragraph but excels at standardized bubbling is not being well-educated.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the claim in Text 1 that standardized tests provide a valuable consistent measure of student learning?
- ABy arguing that what tests measure is too narrow to count as a meaningful representation of student learningCorrect
- BBy acknowledging that achievement gap data from tests have been useful in identifying under-resourced schools
- CBy suggesting that the real problem is that students do not take standardized tests seriously enough
- DBy agreeing that consistent measurement is valuable but proposing that schools use portfolio assessments as a supplement
Why A is right
Text 2 argues that tests 'measure what is easy to measure, not what is most important,' directly challenging the idea that they provide a valuable measure of learning. The author of Text 2 would dispute the assumption that test scores reflect genuine learning.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because Text 2 does not acknowledge any positive uses of achievement gap data; its critique is fundamental, not partial.
- C
- Incorrect because Text 2 does not discuss student effort or test-taking seriousness; it questions what tests are capable of measuring.
- D
- Incorrect because Text 2 does not suggest supplementing tests with portfolios; it challenges the value of test measurement itself.