A Chinese admiral's log, Yongle era (c. 1415): 'We departed from Nanjing with sixty-two great ships and twenty-seven thousand men. We sailed to Malacca, Calicut, Hormuz, and reached the shores of Africa, where the local king presented us with a giraffe for the Emperor. We distributed gifts of silk and porcelain and received in return tribute and acknowledgment of the Emperor's supremacy. The sea belongs to those who can command it.'
The sentiments expressed most directly reflect which of the following?
- AZheng He's voyages as tributary diplomacy meant to project Ming imperial prestige and draw distant kingdoms into a Sinocentric tribute order through gifts and symbolic submissionCorrect
- BThe Yongle Emperor's effort to chart new sea routes to Europe that would bypass the Arab and Portuguese merchants who controlled the lucrative overland and maritime trade in luxury goods
- CThe Ming dynasty's drive to build a profit-seeking commercial maritime empire anchored by permanent trading colonies and fortified outposts established throughout the ports of the Indian Ocean
- DZheng He's voyages as military expeditions intended to conquer and colonize the port cities of the Indian Ocean littoral and place them under direct Ming administrative rule
Why A is right
Zheng He's seven voyages (1405-1433) exemplified the Chinese tributary system: the voyages were not primarily commercial profit-seeking but demonstrations of imperial magnificence. Gifts were distributed, tribute and symbolic acknowledgment were received, and the giraffe (presented to the court as a qilin, a mythological auspicious creature) served to enhance the Yongle Emperor's prestige. The expeditions extended the tributary network, not a commercial or colonial empire.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Zheng He's voyages predated sustained European contact with East Asia by nearly a century; there is no evidence the Yongle Emperor sought routes to Europe or had knowledge of Portuguese traders, who had not yet reached the Indian Ocean.
- C
- The Ming voyages did not establish permanent trading colonies or build a commercial maritime empire; they were diplomatic exhibitions, not profit-driven ventures, and the Ming court ultimately discontinued them partly because they were expensive rather than profitable.
- D
- Zheng He's fleets did occasionally use military force, as at Malacca and Ceylon, but the primary goal was tribute and diplomatic recognition rather than conquest, colonization, or the imposition of direct administrative control over foreign ports.
"The Ming Dynasty's tribute system required foreign rulers to acknowledge Chinese superiority by sending embassies bearing gifts to the imperial court. In return, the emperor bestowed titles, gifts, and trading privileges that often exceeded the value of the tribute received. This system was not primarily economic but diplomatic: it established China as the center of a hierarchical international order in East Asia. Korea, Vietnam, the Ryukyu Kingdom, and various Southeast Asian states participated, sending regular embassies and adopting Chinese calendar systems and court rituals." -- Diplomatic historian's analysis.
The tribute system described in the passage is best understood as
- Aa commercial arrangement designed mainly to maximize China's profits from controlling regional trade routes
- Ba diplomatic framework that established a hierarchical East Asian order centered on China and its cultural prestigeCorrect
- Ca network of military alliances that obligated tributary states to supply soldiers for China's frontier wars
- Dan imperial structure imposed through Chinese military conquest and direct rule over neighboring states
Why B is right
The passage explicitly states the tribute system 'was not primarily economic but diplomatic' and describes it as establishing 'China as the center of a hierarchical international order.' The system functioned through diplomatic recognition of Chinese superiority, gift exchange, and cultural adoption (calendar systems, court rituals) -- a framework centered on cultural prestige rather than military or economic coercion.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage states the system was 'not primarily economic' and notes the emperor's return gifts often exceeded the tribute received, indicating diplomatic rather than profit-maximizing motivations.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage describes the exchange of gifts, titles, and trading privileges, not military obligations; tributary states were not required to furnish soldiers.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage describes voluntary participation through diplomatic embassies and the adoption of Chinese ritual, not conquest or direct administration; states like Korea and Vietnam took part willingly.