"The Marshall Plan was not merely an act of generosity; it was a calculated investment in the stability of Western Europe. A continent devastated by war, its people hungry and desperate, would be fertile ground for communist agitation. By providing billions of dollars in aid for reconstruction, the United States ensured that the nations of Western Europe would rebuild their economies along capitalist lines and remain firmly within the American sphere of influence. The plan succeeded beyond all expectations: within a decade, Western Europe was prosperous, democratic, and allied with Washington."
— Original practice text
A historian would most likely use this source to support which of the following arguments?
- AAmerican foreign aid during the Cold War served both economic and strategic geopolitical objectivesCorrect
- BThe Marshall Plan was primarily motivated by humanitarian concern for European civilian populations
- CThe Marshall Plan was universally accepted without controversy by both American and European leaders
- DSoviet economic models proved more effective than capitalism in rebuilding post-war Europe
Why A is right
The passage explicitly characterizes the Marshall Plan as both aid and a 'calculated investment' serving strategic goals — preventing communist expansion and keeping Europe within the American sphere — supporting the argument that Cold War aid served dual economic and geopolitical purposes.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the passage explicitly states the Plan was 'not merely an act of generosity' but a strategic calculation, emphasizing geopolitical motives over purely humanitarian ones.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage does not address the reception of the Marshall Plan; it focuses on its strategic rationale and outcomes.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage describes Western Europe becoming 'prosperous' under capitalist reconstruction, not Soviet economic models.