"The introduction of the power loom has rendered the labour of the handloom weaver almost entirely valueless. Thousands of families in the manufacturing districts have been reduced to the most abject state of wretchedness. The operative weavers, once the most prosperous class of artisans in England, now subsist upon wages scarcely sufficient to maintain animal existence. Their children grow up stunted and ignorant, and their homes are scenes of unutterable misery."
— Report to Parliament on the Condition of Handloom Weavers, 1840
Which of the following historical developments most directly contributed to the conditions described in the source?
- AThe abolition of the guild system removed the traditional protections that had safeguarded skilled artisan wages
- BIndustrial mechanization of textile production displaced traditional artisan handloom labor, as power looms produced cloth far more cheaplyCorrect
- CMercantilist trade policies sharply restricted imports of cheaper foreign textiles into the British market
- DThe enclosure movement forced displaced agricultural workers into cities, where they competed for scarce factory jobs
Why B is right
The source directly describes how the power loom made handloom weaving economically unviable, which is a direct consequence of industrial mechanization. The Industrial Revolution's introduction of machine-powered textile production, which turned out cloth far more cheaply than hand labor, systematically displaced traditional hand-based artisan labor, creating the impoverishment described.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because although guild dissolution did weaken artisan protections, the source explicitly identifies the power loom as the cause of handloom weavers' decline, pointing to technological change rather than institutional change.
- C
- Incorrect because mercantilist import restrictions would have protected domestic weavers rather than harming them; the source describes a domestic technological displacement, not foreign trade competition.
- D
- Incorrect because while enclosure did drive rural-to-urban migration, the source specifically attributes the weavers' decline to the power loom rather than labor market competition from displaced agricultural workers.