"The Iranian hostage crisis of 1979-1981, in which fifty-two American diplomats and citizens were held for 444 days, fundamentally altered the relationship between the United States and the Islamic world. The crisis demonstrated that the old certainties of Cold War geopolitics — in which the Middle East was a chessboard for superpower competition — were being swept aside by forces that neither Washington nor Moscow understood. Political Islam had emerged as an independent force, motivated neither by capitalism nor communism but by its own vision of justice, governance, and the relationship between religion and the state."
— International relations historian, 2000
The emergence of political Islam as described in this passage most significantly challenged which of the following frameworks for understanding international relations?
- AThe democratic peace theory, which held that liberal democracies almost never wage war against one another and would therefore tend toward stable cooperation
- BThe theory of economic determinism, which argued that all major political conflicts are ultimately rooted in competition over material resources and class interests
- CThe bipolar Cold War framework, which assumed that significant political movements could be classified as aligned with either the Western or the Soviet blocCorrect
- DThe theory of the end of history, which held that liberal democracy had permanently triumphed and that ideological evolution had effectively reached its endpoint
Why C is right
The passage explicitly states that political Islam was 'motivated neither by capitalism nor communism' and that it challenged the assumption that Middle Eastern politics could be understood through the lens of superpower competition. This directly challenged the bipolar Cold War framework that categorized all political movements as pro-Western or pro-Soviet.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because democratic peace theory concerns relations between democracies, which is not the focus of the passage; the challenge described is to the Cold War's bipolar worldview rather than to democratic peace theory.
- B
- Incorrect because while political Islam challenges economic determinism, the passage specifically frames its challenge in terms of the Cold War's bipolar framework rather than economic theory.
- D
- Incorrect because the 'end of history' thesis was articulated by Francis Fukuyama in 1989, after the events described; the hostage crisis predated and foreshadowed challenges to that thesis rather than directly responding to it.