"The Responsibility to Protect, adopted by the United Nations in 2005, declares that when a state fails to protect its citizens from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, and crimes against humanity, the international community has the authority to intervene. This principle was invoked to justify NATO's military intervention in Libya in 2011. But what was presented as a humanitarian mission to protect civilians quickly became a campaign for regime change. The precedent has poisoned the well: Russia and China now veto any Security Council resolution that might authorize intervention, citing Libya as proof that humanitarian language masks imperial ambitions."
— International relations scholar, 2015
The developments described in this passage best illustrate which of the following dilemmas in contemporary international politics?
- AThe emergence of universal agreement among the major powers that humanitarian intervention should be automatically authorized whenever any civilian population is threatened with violence
- BThe proven success of the Responsibility to Protect doctrine in preventing all genocides, war crimes, and mass atrocities in the years since its adoption by the United Nations
- CThe tension between humanitarian intervention as a principle and its potential misuse as a pretext for great-power interference in sovereign statesCorrect
- DThe declining relevance of the United Nations Security Council, which can no longer shape outcomes when major powers confront global security challenges and crises
Why C is right
The passage describes how the legitimate humanitarian principle of R2P was applied in Libya but perceived by other major powers as a cover for regime change, making them unwilling to authorize future interventions. This illustrates the core dilemma between genuine humanitarian protection and the risk that intervention norms will be exploited for geopolitical purposes.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage explicitly describes disagreement among major powers, with Russia and China blocking intervention resolutions; there is no universal agreement on when humanitarian intervention should be authorized.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage describes the principle being undermined by the Libya precedent, with subsequent vetoes preventing its application; R2P has not successfully prevented all mass atrocities.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage shows the Security Council remains centrally important — its veto mechanism directly determines whether interventions can be authorized, demonstrating continued relevance rather than declining importance.