"The garment factories of Bangladesh employ four million workers, ninety percent of them women. The wages are low by any global standard, the hours are long, and the buildings — as the Rana Plaza collapse of 2013 revealed — are sometimes structurally dangerous. And yet for millions of rural women, factory work represents the first income they have ever controlled. The question is not simply whether these conditions are just, but who gets to define justice for workers whose alternatives are significantly worse."
— Development economist, Dhaka, 2014
A historian could best use this source to support which argument?
- AThat global manufacturing supply chains bring developing nations real economic gains for workers alongside serious labor rights concernsCorrect
- BThat Bangladesh's government deliberately preserved dangerous factory conditions to attract foreign investment from Western brands
- CThat global supply chains in the clothing industry systematically exploit workers in the developing world while providing them no meaningful economic benefit whatsoever
- DThat Western consumers, through their everyday purchases, bear full moral responsibility for unsafe conditions in global supply chains
Why A is right
The economist presents a nuanced view: factory conditions are poor and dangerous, yet they represent economic opportunity for workers whose alternatives are worse. This supports an argument that global supply chains produce genuine but complicated development outcomes — neither straightforwardly exploitative nor straightforwardly beneficial. The Rana Plaza collapse and the economic empowerment data together illustrate this ambiguity.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- The source describes conditions and a debate about justice but makes no claim about the Bangladeshi government deliberately maintaining danger to lure investment; this reads far more into the evidence than it supports.
- C
- The source explicitly states that factory work gives women their 'first income they have ever controlled' — a meaningful economic benefit; arguing the system provides no benefit directly contradicts the passage.
- D
- The source raises a question about who gets to define justice but does not place full responsibility on Western consumers; it points to multiple stakeholders and to workers' constrained alternatives.