"The phenomenon of 'land grabbing' — the large-scale acquisition of farmland in developing countries by foreign governments and multinational corporations — has accelerated dramatically since the global food price crisis of 2008. Saudi Arabia, China, South Korea, and other food-importing nations have leased or purchased millions of hectares of agricultural land in Africa, Southeast Asia, and Latin America to grow food for export to their own populations. The host countries, many of which struggle to feed their own citizens, are selling their most valuable asset — fertile land — to foreign entities that will extract its productivity and ship it abroad."
— Food security researcher, 2018
The economic relationship described in this passage most directly parallels which of the following historical patterns?
- ATwentieth-century land reform programs that broke up large estates and redistributed plots to smallholder farmers in order to strengthen local food sovereignty
- BFair trade certification systems that guarantee minimum prices and a social premium to agricultural cooperatives among producers in the developing world
- CThe Green Revolution's introduction of high-yield crop varieties to raise food production within developing countries for domestic consumption
- DColonial extraction economies in which colonized lands produced commodities for metropolitan markets while local populations remained food-insecureCorrect
Why D is right
The passage describes foreign entities acquiring agricultural land in developing countries to grow food for export while host populations remain food-insecure. This directly parallels colonial extraction economies, where colonized territories produced cash crops for metropolitan markets while local populations suffered food scarcity — the same pattern of resource extraction benefiting external consumers at the expense of local needs.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because land reform redistributes land to local smallholders, while the passage describes the opposite process — concentrating land ownership in the hands of foreign governments and corporations.
- B
- Incorrect because fair trade seeks equitable compensation for local producers, while the passage describes large-scale acquisition by foreign entities that extracts productivity for export — a fundamentally different economic relationship.
- C
- Incorrect because the Green Revolution aimed to increase food production for domestic consumption within developing countries, while land grabbing exports food production to foreign markets — opposite purposes.
"The Green Revolution saved millions from starvation, of this there is no doubt. The high-yield varieties of wheat and rice developed by Borlaug and his colleagues transformed agriculture in India, Mexico, and the Philippines. But the revolution came at a price that is only now becoming clear. The new seeds required expensive fertilizers, pesticides, and irrigation systems that only wealthy farmers could afford. Smallholders were driven from their land. Monoculture replaced biodiversity. Groundwater tables fell as irrigation pumped aquifers dry. We traded long-term sustainability for short-term abundance."
— Agricultural scientist, 2005
The developments described in this passage best illustrate which of the following tensions in the modern world?
- AThe tension between short-term humanitarian gains in food supply and long-term environmental sustainabilityCorrect
- BThe conflict between preserving traditional farming cultures and adopting modern industrial scientific methods
- CThe disagreement between capitalist and socialist models of organizing national agricultural production
- DThe competition between developed and developing nations for control of global food supply chains
Why A is right
The passage explicitly describes how the Green Revolution produced immediate humanitarian benefits (saving millions from starvation) but created long-term environmental problems (depleted aquifers, lost biodiversity, monoculture). This trade-off between short-term gains and long-term sustainability is the central tension the passage identifies.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the passage does not frame the issue as a conflict between tradition and modernity; it acknowledges the scientific achievements while critiquing their environmental consequences, a different kind of tension.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage does not discuss capitalist versus socialist models of agriculture; it addresses the environmental and social consequences of a specific technological approach regardless of economic system.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage focuses on the internal consequences of the Green Revolution within developing countries rather than on competition between developed and developing nations over food supply chains.