"The rise of authoritarian capitalism — exemplified by China, Russia, and the Gulf states — has challenged the post-Cold War assumption that economic modernization inevitably leads to democratic governance. These nations have achieved significant economic growth while maintaining political systems that restrict civil liberties, suppress opposition, and concentrate power in the hands of ruling elites. They offer an alternative model to developing nations seeking economic growth: prosperity without democracy, development without dissent, modernity without liberalism."
— Political economy researcher, 2020
The developments described in this passage most directly challenge which of the following theories?
- ARealist theory, which argues that international relations are determined by the balance of military power among states
- BWorld-systems theory, which divides the global economy into core, semi-periphery, and periphery nations
- CDependency theory, which argues that developing nations are kept poor by their economic relationship with wealthy nations
- DModernization theory, which predicts that economic development will produce democratic political institutionsCorrect
Why D is right
The passage explicitly describes nations achieving economic modernization without democratizing, directly challenging modernization theory's prediction that economic development inevitably leads to democratic governance. The existence of prosperous authoritarian states demonstrates that the theorized link between economic development and democratization is not automatic.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because realist theory concerns international power dynamics among states rather than the domestic political consequences of economic modernization.
- B
- Incorrect because world-systems theory categorizes nations by their position in the global economic hierarchy rather than predicting political outcomes of economic development.
- C
- Incorrect because dependency theory concerns the structural economic relationship between wealthy and poor nations rather than the connection between economic development and democracy that the passage addresses.