A Byzantine chronicler, Account of the Fall of Constantinople (1453): 'The Sultan entered the city in triumph, riding a white horse. He ordered that the great church of Hagia Sophia be converted at once into a mosque. The Christian empire, which had stood for over a thousand years, was extinguished in a single afternoon. The Sultan wept when he saw the ruined palaces, saying: what city have we given over to plunder and destruction?'
A historian could best use this source to support which argument?
- AOttoman rulers were indifferent to the architectural and cultural heritage of the cities they conquered
- BThe fall of Constantinople in 1453 marked the definitive end of the Western Roman Empire's political legacy in Europe
- CThe Ottoman conquest combined military triumph with ambivalence toward the vanquished Byzantine civilizationCorrect
- DByzantine resistance successfully preserved most Christian institutions within the Ottoman Empire
Why C is right
The source shows Mehmed II celebrating victory while expressing grief at the city's destruction — a nuanced portrayal of Ottoman attitudes. This supports an argument about Ottoman rulers' complex relationship with conquered cultures, simultaneously transforming institutions (Hagia Sophia) while lamenting cultural loss.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The Sultan's reported weeping over the ruined palaces directly contradicts indifference to cultural heritage.
- B
- The Western Roman Empire had already fallen in 476 CE; Constantinople was the Eastern Roman Empire's capital, so its fall does not mark the end of a Western legacy.
- D
- While the Ottoman Empire did tolerate some Christian practices, the source emphasizes the conversion of Hagia Sophia, not the preservation of Byzantine Christian institutions.
"The Ottomans have conquered Constantinople and now style themselves heirs of Rome. Their armies march into Hungary while their fleet commands the eastern Mediterranean. The silk routes through Persia are under their hand, and the spices of the East pass through their markets at great profit."
— Fictional composite representing documented European diplomatic correspondence, c. 1453–1520 CE
The situation described in this account most directly encouraged which of the following responses from European states?
- AEuropean scholars abandoned interest in Greek and Roman learning because the Ottomans now controlled classical sources
- BEuropean merchants and monarchs sought sea routes to Asia that bypassed Ottoman-controlled overland routesCorrect
- CEuropean states accepted Ottoman commercial dominance and relied entirely on Ottoman-controlled spice trade
- DEuropean powers formed military alliances with the Ottoman Empire to challenge the Safavid Persian state
Why B is right
The Ottoman Empire's control over Silk Road routes and eastern Mediterranean commerce increased the costs of Asian goods reaching Europe, providing a powerful economic incentive for Europeans to seek alternative sea routes. Portugal's exploration of the African coast and eventual rounding of the Cape of Good Hope (1488, 1498), as well as Spain's westward voyages, were partly motivated by the desire to access Asian spices and goods while bypassing Ottoman middlemen. This contributed directly to the Age of Exploration.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the fall of Constantinople actually accelerated the spread of Greek learning to Italy when Byzantine scholars fled westward with manuscripts, contributing to the Renaissance rather than suppressing classical study.
- C
- Incorrect because European merchants and states were not content to passively accept Ottoman commercial dominance. The search for alternative routes was a direct response to Ottoman control of overland commerce.
- D
- Incorrect because while European states occasionally sought tactical alliances against the Ottomans, they did not ally with the Ottomans against Safavid Persia. European-Ottoman relations were primarily adversarial, especially in the Mediterranean.