"The American and French Revolutions drew upon Enlightenment principles of natural rights, popular sovereignty, and the social contract. The American Declaration of Independence proclaimed that 'all men are created equal' with 'unalienable rights' to 'life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.' The French Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen similarly declared the 'natural and imprescriptible rights of man.' Yet both revolutions fell short of their universal language: the American Revolution preserved slavery, and the French Revolution initially excluded women from political participation. These contradictions would fuel further struggles for equality in subsequent centuries." -- Political historian's analysis.
The contradictions identified in the passage best demonstrate which of the following?
- AThe principles of natural rights and popular sovereignty exerted no meaningful influence on political or constitutional developments after the eighteenth century
- BEnlightenment thinkers across Europe universally rejected and condemned all forms of political and social revolution as threats to ordered liberty
- CThe revolutions' guiding Enlightenment principles were applied inconsistently, creating gaps between proclaimed ideals and actual practiceCorrect
- DThe American and French Revolutions achieved complete and lasting social equality for all people regardless of race, gender, or class
Why C is right
The passage describes revolutionary declarations proclaiming universal equality while simultaneously preserving slavery (America) and excluding women (France). This inconsistency between proclaimed ideals and actual practice demonstrates that Enlightenment principles were applied selectively, creating contradictions that 'would fuel further struggles for equality in subsequent centuries.'
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage states these contradictions 'would fuel further struggles for equality in subsequent centuries,' indicating the continued influence of these principles.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage describes Enlightenment principles as the intellectual foundation of the revolutions, indicating support for rather than opposition to political change.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage explicitly identifies the preservation of slavery and the exclusion of women as evidence that complete social equality was not achieved.