"The Zulu impis have surrounded the British column at Isandlwana and destroyed it entirely. In London, this is called a catastrophe. In Zululand, it is called a victory. The newspaper says it is impossible that a European army could be defeated by Africans with spears."
— Fictional composite representing documented accounts of the Battle of Isandlwana, 1879 CE
The Battle of Isandlwana (1879), in which Zulu forces destroyed a British army column, most directly challenges which of the following assumptions underlying European imperialism?
- AThe economic premise that imperial expansion was driven primarily by the need for new export markets and access to raw materials abroad
- BThe Social Darwinist argument that conquered peoples had inferior cultures rather than inferior military technology
- CThe belief that Europeans were technologically superior and therefore inevitably victorious against non-European peoples in battleCorrect
- DThe humanitarian 'civilizing mission' rationale that depicted colonial rule as a benevolent effort to uplift and develop subject populations
Why C is right
Isandlwana challenged the assumption of European military invincibility. The Zulu impi's tactical victory over a British regular army column (killing approximately 1,300 British and allied soldiers) demonstrated that disciplined non-European warriors with traditional weapons could defeat modern European armies when conditions favored their tactical strengths. Like the Russo-Japanese War later, such defeats revealed that European victory was conditional, not inevitable, and depended on specific technological and tactical advantages that could be countered.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the economic justification for imperialism concerned commercial interests and resource access, not military assumptions. The battle's significance was military, not economic.
- B
- Incorrect because Social Darwinism concerned cultural hierarchy, not specifically military assumptions. The battle's immediate impact was on the claim of European military invincibility, not on broader cultural hierarchies.
- D
- Incorrect because the civilizing mission rhetoric concerned cultural and developmental hierarchies, not military assumptions. The battle challenged beliefs about military technology and tactics, not humanitarian rationales.