Asian States and European Merchants and Missionaries, 1550–1750
All seven documents are original practice composites written for ScoreGrind. Each one reflects a real, documented position from its time and place.
Document 1 — Composite based on letters from Italian Jesuit missionaries in Beijing to their superiors in Rome, c. 1605: The scholars come to our house every day. But they come to see the clocks, the world map and the glass prisms. They ask us to explain eclipses and to correct their calendar. When we turn the talk to the soul, they grow polite and leave. We now wear the robes of their scholars and quote their sage Confucius. Without these things we would not be allowed to stay in the capital one week.
Document 2 — Composite based on the Tokugawa shogunate’s orders to the magistrates of Nagasaki, 1639: Ships from Portugal have carried priests into this country in secret. Their teaching has turned subjects against their lords. From now on no Portuguese ship may enter any harbor. If one arrives, burn it and execute those aboard. The Dutch, who do not spread the forbidden faith, may continue to trade under the watch of our officials.
Document 3 — Composite based on accounts by a German physician employed by the Dutch East India Company at Dejima, describing the company’s yearly visit to the shogun in Edo, c. 1692: We are kept on a small island no bigger than a city square, and we may not cross its bridge without a guard. Each year our chief travels to Edo to thank the shogun for permission to trade. In the palace we were ordered to walk, dance, sing and speak Dutch while the court watched from behind screens. The company accepts all of this. The profit from Japanese copper is too large to give up.
Document 4 — Composite based on Mughal court correspondence with the English East India Company, c. 1618: The English captain has asked to trade at the port of Surat. We grant it as a favor, as we grant favors to many merchants who come from distant lands to our ports. His ships may buy and sell under the protection of our governors, and his men must obey our laws. Let the king of the English send rare goods worthy of our court, and his merchants will be welcome.
Document 5 — Composite based on reports from Spanish royal officials in Manila to the king of Spain, 1640: This city lives on the Chinese. Their junks bring the silk and porcelain that our galleon carries to Acapulco. They also bring the rice and meat we eat. Without them Manila would starve in a month. Yet they are many times our number. Last year they rose against us, and only our soldiers and our Filipino allies put them down, with great slaughter.
Document 6 — Composite based on the Kangxi emperor’s comments on the papal decree banning Chinese rites, 1721: The Westerners have served us well in astronomy and in casting cannon. But this decree from their pope tells Chinese Christians they may not honor Confucius or their ancestors. These men cannot read our books, yet they judge our teachings. From this day they may not preach in China. Those with useful skills may stay at court.
Document 7 — Composite based on reports from the governor-general of the Dutch East India Company in Batavia to the company’s directors, 1621: The Banda Islands are now ours. Their people broke their promise to sell nutmeg only to the company, so we have conquered them. Most are dead, fled or shipped away as captives. We will divide their nutmeg groves among Dutch settlers, worked by enslaved laborers. No other nation will buy a single nutmeg here again.
- (1)Evaluate the extent to which Asian states controlled the terms of their contact with European merchants and missionaries in the period 1550–1750.