Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Document-Based Question (DBQ)

7 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

The DBQ is the first question in Section II of the AP World History: Modern exam, the essay section. It comes after Section I, which holds the multiple-choice questions and, in Part B, the three short-answer questions. The Long Essay follows the DBQ. You get one question and seven documents. The documents are usually written texts, though one may be a map, chart or image. You have 60 minutes for it, and the exam recommends spending the first 15 of them reading the documents and planning. The DBQ is worth 25% of your total exam score. That makes it the single heaviest task on the test, heavier than all three short-answer questions together (20%) and the long essay (15%). Together, the free-response questions (SAQs in Section I, DBQ and LEQ in Section II) are 60% of your score. Section II alone is 40%.

On this page · 6 sections

The DBQ is scored out of 7 points on a fixed rubric. Each point is judged on its own. Missing the thesis does not stop you earning the evidence points, and a messy essay can still score 6. Readers do not mark grammar, spelling or style. They check for six things: a thesis, contextualization, document evidence (2 points), evidence beyond the documents, sourcing, and complex understanding. DBQ topics come from 1450 onward, so most prompts land in Units 3–9. Units 3 and 4 (land and maritime empires) and Units 5 and 6 (revolutions, industrialization and imperialism) carry the biggest share of the course.

The question almost always asks you to evaluate a claim: “Evaluate the extent to which…” Your job is not to summarize seven documents. It is to make an argument and use the documents as proof. Readers reward a clear answer that groups documents by idea. They do not reward an essay that walks through Doc 1, then Doc 2, then Doc 3.

The rubric, in plain terms

7 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Thesis / Claim1 pt

Give a defensible answer to the prompt that sets up a line of reasoning. It must sit in one place, in the introduction or the conclusion, and can be one or two sentences. Repeating the question does not count. “Asian states controlled contact with Europeans” fails. “Large land empires controlled contact by taking European trade and science while limiting Christianity, but small island states could not” earns it.

Contextualization1 pt

Describe the bigger historical situation leading up to or surrounding the prompt’s time period, and tie it to the topic. Names and dates make the point safe. For a 1550–1750 prompt on Asian–European contact, explain the Portuguese entry into the Indian Ocean after 1498 and Spanish silver reaching China through Manila after 1571. A single loose phrase like “during the Age of Exploration” almost never earns it.

Evidence from the documents2 pts

You earn 1 point for accurately describing the content of at least three documents in a way that addresses the topic. You earn both points for using at least four documents to support your argument. Each of those four must back up a claim you are making, not just be retold. Cite documents as (Doc 3) and paraphrase them. If you misread a document, it does not count toward the four.

Evidence beyond the documents1 pt

Use at least one specific piece of evidence that is not in any document, and explain how it supports your argument. It must be concrete, such as the Shimabara Rebellion of 1637 or the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. A vague “other events” does not count. It also cannot be something a document already gives you. A fact that is accurate but unconnected to your argument earns nothing.

Sourcing1 pt

For at least two documents, explain how or why the author’s point of view, purpose, historical situation, or audience matters to your argument. “He is biased” earns nothing. It earns the point when you explain why the source matters. Example: a Jesuit writing to superiors who wanted converts had every reason to boast, so when he admits failure at conversion, you can believe him.

Complex understanding1 pt

Show a deeper, more complicated grasp of the question, and make it part of your argument. It can appear in any part of the essay; it does not have to run through every paragraph. Proven routes include explaining where and why your claim stops being true, or weighing several causes or variables and ranking them. You can also explain both similarity and difference, or both continuity and change, or connect the topic to another period. Another route is to qualify your thesis with documents or evidence that cut against it. One “however” sentence that is never developed does not earn it.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Asian States and European Merchants and Missionaries, 1550–1750

All seven documents are original practice composites written for ScoreGrind. Each one reflects a real, documented position from its time and place.

Document 1 — Composite based on letters from Italian Jesuit missionaries in Beijing to their superiors in Rome, c. 1605: The scholars come to our house every day. But they come to see the clocks, the world map and the glass prisms. They ask us to explain eclipses and to correct their calendar. When we turn the talk to the soul, they grow polite and leave. We now wear the robes of their scholars and quote their sage Confucius. Without these things we would not be allowed to stay in the capital one week.

Document 2 — Composite based on the Tokugawa shogunate’s orders to the magistrates of Nagasaki, 1639: Ships from Portugal have carried priests into this country in secret. Their teaching has turned subjects against their lords. From now on no Portuguese ship may enter any harbor. If one arrives, burn it and execute those aboard. The Dutch, who do not spread the forbidden faith, may continue to trade under the watch of our officials.

Document 3 — Composite based on accounts by a German physician employed by the Dutch East India Company at Dejima, describing the company’s yearly visit to the shogun in Edo, c. 1692: We are kept on a small island no bigger than a city square, and we may not cross its bridge without a guard. Each year our chief travels to Edo to thank the shogun for permission to trade. In the palace we were ordered to walk, dance, sing and speak Dutch while the court watched from behind screens. The company accepts all of this. The profit from Japanese copper is too large to give up.

Document 4 — Composite based on Mughal court correspondence with the English East India Company, c. 1618: The English captain has asked to trade at the port of Surat. We grant it as a favor, as we grant favors to many merchants who come from distant lands to our ports. His ships may buy and sell under the protection of our governors, and his men must obey our laws. Let the king of the English send rare goods worthy of our court, and his merchants will be welcome.

Document 5 — Composite based on reports from Spanish royal officials in Manila to the king of Spain, 1640: This city lives on the Chinese. Their junks bring the silk and porcelain that our galleon carries to Acapulco. They also bring the rice and meat we eat. Without them Manila would starve in a month. Yet they are many times our number. Last year they rose against us, and only our soldiers and our Filipino allies put them down, with great slaughter.

Document 6 — Composite based on the Kangxi emperor’s comments on the papal decree banning Chinese rites, 1721: The Westerners have served us well in astronomy and in casting cannon. But this decree from their pope tells Chinese Christians they may not honor Confucius or their ancestors. These men cannot read our books, yet they judge our teachings. From this day they may not preach in China. Those with useful skills may stay at court.

Document 7 — Composite based on reports from the governor-general of the Dutch East India Company in Batavia to the company’s directors, 1621: The Banda Islands are now ours. Their people broke their promise to sell nutmeg only to the company, so we have conquered them. Most are dead, fled or shipped away as captives. We will divide their nutmeg groves among Dutch settlers, worked by enslaved laborers. No other nation will buy a single nutmeg here again.

  1. (1)Evaluate the extent to which Asian states controlled the terms of their contact with European merchants and missionaries in the period 1550–1750.
Prompt 2

Economic Forces and Global Migration, 1850–1914

All seven documents are original practice composites written for ScoreGrind. Each one reflects a real, documented position from its time and place.

Document 1 — Composite based on letters from Chinese miners in California to their families in Guangdong, 1855: I send forty dollars with this letter. Use it to pay the debt on the land and to buy rice before spring. The work in the river is hard, and the Americans make us pay a special tax that they do not pay. Still, one month here earns more than a year at home, where the rebels and the floods have ruined everything.

Document 2 — Composite based on reports by British emigration agents recruiting laborers in northern India for the sugar estates of Trinidad, 1879: Recruiting has been easy this season. The rains failed in the districts around Allahabad, and grain prices doubled. Men come to the depot with nothing. Each signs a contract for five years of work on the estates at fixed wages, with free passage home after ten years in the colony. Few of them know where Trinidad lies.

Document 3 — Composite based on letters from Italian farm laborers in Argentina to family in Piedmont, 1888: Come in October for the harvest. A man earns here in five months what he earns at home in two years. The steamship costs less than before. Many of us go back to Italy for our own harvest and return here the next season. The landowners here need hands more than anything.

Document 4 — Composite based on Japanese prefectural notices recruiting workers for the sugar plantations of the Kingdom of Hawaii, 1885: The Hawaiian government seeks strong farmers for three years of plantation work. Wages are nine dollars a month with housing, and the voyage is paid. The workers’ savings will help their home villages, which suffer from the new land tax and falling rice prices.

Document 5 — Composite based on speeches by the leader of a workingmen’s political party in San Francisco, 1877: The Chinese work for wages no white man can live on. The railroad companies and factory owners bring them here by the shipload to break our wages. We demand that Congress stop them from coming. Until it does, we will not rest.

Document 6 — Composite based on memoirs of Jewish women who left the Russian Empire for New York, here a woman who left in 1906, written in the 1930s: My father was a tailor, and we were poor. But poverty was not why we left. In October the mob came through our town for three days. They burned the shops and killed our neighbor in the street while the police watched. My uncle in New York sent tickets for the ship. We went because we were afraid to stay.

Document 7 — Composite based on speeches by an Indian member of the Imperial Legislative Council calling for an end to indentured emigration to Natal, 1910: These men are told they go to earn good wages. In truth they are bound for years to employers who may fine them, jail them and beat them. When their term ends, Natal taxes them for daring to stay as free men. This is not free migration. It is a labor trade that shames India.

  1. (1)Evaluate the extent to which economic forces caused large-scale migration in the period 1850–1914.

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Asian States and European Merchants and Missionaries, 1550–1750 · high-scoring response7/7

In the early 1500s, Portuguese ships pushed into the Indian Ocean after Vasco da Gama reached India in 1498. The Portuguese tried to control trade by force. They seized Goa in 1510 and Malacca in 1511 and made Asian ships buy passes called cartazes. After 1571, Spanish silver from Potosí flowed to Asia through Manila, because Ming China needed silver to pay taxes. For the first time Europeans had something Asia badly wanted. But they arrived as small groups of merchants and priests. They faced huge land empires: Ming and then Qing China, Mughal India, and a Japan united under the Tokugawa after 1600.

From 1550 to 1750, the large Asian land empires mostly controlled the terms of contact. They accepted European trade and technical skill but limited or banned European religion. In the small island societies of Southeast Asia, though, Europeans used force to set the terms themselves. So Asian control depended on the strength of the state.

The strongest states treated Europeans as guests who had to follow local rules. Doc 4 shows the Mughal court granting the English the right to trade at Surat “as a favor,” the same favor given to many foreign merchants. The source matters. It was written for the English king, and its purpose was to show the emperor’s superior rank. That tone matched reality. When the English East India Company fought the Mughals under Aurangzeb in the 1680s, it lost and had to beg for its trading rights back.

Japan was even stricter. In Doc 2 the shogun bans Portuguese ships and threatens to burn them, but lets the Dutch stay. Doc 3 shows how far the Dutch bent to keep that trade. They lived on a tiny island and even danced for the court. The author worked for the Dutch company, so he had no reason to exaggerate his own company’s humiliation. That makes his account strong proof that Japan, not the Dutch, set the rules. This was not total isolation. Japan picked who it traded with and on what terms.

China also chose what it wanted. In Doc 1 a Jesuit admits that scholars came for clocks and maps but left when he talked about religion. He was writing to superiors in Rome who wanted converts. When he admits failure, he is believable. In Doc 6 the Kangxi emperor bans preaching after the pope attacked Chinese rites, but keeps Jesuits with useful skills. The Chinese state took the science and rejected the faith.

Europeans did set the terms where states were small. In Doc 7 the Dutch company conquered the Banda Islands and killed or enslaved most of the people to control nutmeg. The Bandanese had no army or navy that could resist. Doc 5 is more complicated. The Spanish ruled Manila and crushed a Chinese uprising. But the official admits Manila would starve without Chinese merchants. So even where Europeans held political power, they depended on Asian trade networks and on China’s demand for silver. Control was not simply yes or no.

Overall, Asian states controlled contact to a large extent, but only the large land empires had the power to do it. Their armies and bureaucracies let them decide which Europeans traded, where, and on what terms. That balance shifted after 1750. The East India Company used Mughal weakness to conquer Bengal after the Battle of Plassey in 1757. Later, industrial Britain forced China open in the Opium War of 1839–42.

How it scored

1/1thesis — The thesis answers the prompt with a qualified claim and a clear line of reasoning: land empires controlled contact by taking trade and science but limiting religion, while small island states could not.
1/1context — The opening develops the situation before 1550 with specifics: da Gama in 1498, Goa and Malacca, the cartaz system, and Potosí silver reaching China through Manila. It ties this to why Europeans arrived needing Asian goodwill.
2/2doc-evidence — All seven documents are used, and far more than four support claims in the argument. Docs 2, 3, 4 and 6 prove state control; Docs 5 and 7 prove its limits.
1/1outside-evidence — The Mughal defeat of the English East India Company under Aurangzeb is specific, appears in no document, and is used to show the Mughal tone in Doc 4 matched real power.
1/1sourcing — Three documents are sourced with relevance explained: Doc 4 (purpose and audience), Doc 3 (point of view of a company employee), Doc 1 (audience of superiors who wanted converts). Two were needed.
1/1complexity — The argument is qualified by state size, and Doc 5 is used to show that even European political control rested on Asian trade. That nuance is part of the argument, not a tacked-on sentence.
Asian States and European Merchants and Missionaries, 1550–1750 · mid-scoring response3/7

During the Age of Exploration, Europeans sailed to Asia because they wanted spices and other goods.

From 1550 to 1750, Asian states controlled their contact with Europeans to a large extent, because they let Europeans trade but kept them under strict rules.

Doc 1 shows an Italian Jesuit in China showing clocks and maps to Chinese scholars. The Jesuits were very successful because of their science, and over time they converted the emperor to Christianity. Doc 6 shows that the emperor later changed his mind and banned preaching. This shows that China controlled contact.

Doc 2 is an order from the Tokugawa shogunate banning Portuguese ships. Japan was afraid of Christianity because of the Shimabara Rebellion in 1637, when Christian peasants rose up against their lords. After this, Japan closed itself off from the whole world. Doc 3 shows the Dutch stuck on a tiny island, which proves Japan was isolated.

Doc 4 shows the Mughals letting the English trade at Surat. The author is biased because he works for the Mughal emperor.

Doc 7 shows the Dutch conquering the Banda Islands for nutmeg and killing most of the people. This shows that Europeans could be very cruel.

Overall, Asian states controlled their contact with Europeans because they were large and powerful empires.

How it scored

1/1thesis — The claim is defensible and gives a reason (trade allowed, under strict rules), which is enough of a line of reasoning to earn the point.
0/1context — One general sentence about the Age of Exploration. It names no events, places or dates and never explains the situation Asian states faced.
1/2doc-evidence — The first point is earned: the content of Docs 2, 4, 6 and 7 is described accurately. The second point is not, because fewer than four documents support the argument. Doc 1 is misread: no Chinese emperor converted, and the document says scholars left when religion came up. Doc 3 is used to prove isolation when it shows Dutch trade continuing. Doc 7 contradicts the thesis and is never connected to it.
1/1outside-evidence — The Shimabara Rebellion of 1637 is specific, is not in any document, and is linked to why Japan banned the Portuguese.
0/1sourcing — Calling the Doc 4 author “biased” without explaining how his position shapes the document or the argument earns nothing, and no second document is sourced.
0/1complexity — The essay treats Japan as totally closed and never deals with the Banda conquest, which would have qualified the thesis. No nuance is attempted.
Economic Forces and Global Migration, 1850–1914 · high-scoring response6/7

In the 1800s, industrialization spread from Britain to the United States, Germany and Japan. Factories needed raw materials like cotton, sugar and rubber, and the plantations and mines that produced them needed workers. At the same time, Britain abolished slavery in its empire in 1833. Planters in the Caribbean and the Indian Ocean lost their source of forced labor and looked for new workers. Steamships and railroads made long journeys cheaper and faster. These changes set up the largest migrations the world had yet seen.

From 1850 to 1914, economic forces caused most large-scale migration. Industrial and plantation economies needed huge numbers of workers, while poor rural regions in Asia and Europe had too little land and too few wages.

The main pull was wages. In Doc 3 an Italian laborer says a man earns in five months in Argentina what takes two years at home. He adds that many go back every year, so these migrants followed the harvest across the ocean. Doc 1 shows the same pull for Chinese miners in California. The writer sends forty dollars home to pay off a land debt. He is writing to his family, so he has a reason to make life sound good. But he still admits the unfair tax, which makes the letter more believable. Money sent home kept whole villages going.

The main push was rural poverty. In Doc 2 a British agent finds recruiting easy because the rains failed and grain prices doubled. In Doc 4 a Japanese office recruits farmers for Hawaii because of a new land tax and falling rice prices. That source is a government notice meant to persuade farmers to sign up. So it stresses savings and says nothing about how hard plantation work was. Even so, it shows a modernizing state using emigration to ease distress at home.

Economic forces also shaped the reaction against migrants. In Doc 5 a workers’ leader in San Francisco attacks Chinese laborers for driving down wages. This anger helped produce the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which banned Chinese laborers from entering the United States. The conflict was about jobs and pay, so even the backlash was economic.

Indentured labor shows how far employers would go to get workers. Doc 7 says indentured Indians in Natal were fined, jailed and beaten, and taxed if they stayed after their contracts. The speaker was an Indian politician whose purpose was to end the system, so he stresses abuses. But the economic motive is clear. Natal’s sugar planters could not recruit enough local African workers on their terms, so they paid for bound Indian labor.

However, not all migration was economic. In Doc 6 a Jewish woman says her family left Russia because of a pogrom, not poverty.

Overall, economic forces caused migration to a very large extent. Wages, debt and the labor needs of industrial economies explain why millions moved.

How it scored

1/1thesis — The thesis takes a clear position and sets up a two-part line of reasoning: pull (labor demand) and push (rural poverty).
1/1context — The opening explains the spread of industrialization, the 1833 abolition of slavery and its effect on planters, and cheaper steam transport, then ties all of it to migration.
2/2doc-evidence — All seven documents are used. Docs 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 7 each support a specific claim in the argument.
1/1outside-evidence — The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 and the 1833 abolition of slavery are specific, outside the documents, and explained in support of the argument.
1/1sourcing — Docs 1, 4 and 7 are sourced, and each explains how the author’s audience or purpose affects what the document can prove.
0/1complexity — Doc 6 shows a non-economic cause, but it gets one sentence and is never weighed against the thesis. The essay does not explain how persecution, or the coercion in indenture, limits its argument. A stated exception is not the same as a qualified argument.
Economic Forces and Global Migration, 1850–1914 · mid-scoring response4/7

During the 1800s, the Industrial Revolution spread from Britain to other countries. Factories and plantations needed workers, and steamships made it cheaper to travel long distances. Many people also faced poverty in the countryside. These changes made migration easier than ever before.

Economic forces caused migration from 1850 to 1914 to a large extent because people wanted better jobs and higher wages.

Many migrants moved because they could earn more money. In Doc 3 an Italian worker says he can earn in five months in Argentina what takes two years in Italy. In Doc 1 a Chinese miner sends forty dollars home to his family. In Doc 4 Japan recruits farmers to work in Hawaii for nine dollars a month. These people all chose to move for better pay.

Doc 5 shows a man in San Francisco who wants to stop Chinese immigration because the Chinese work for low wages. This shows that companies brought Chinese workers for economic reasons, to get cheap labor.

Doc 2 shows Indians going to Trinidad on five-year contracts. They signed contracts, so they also chose to migrate for wages, just like the Italians. Doc 7 is from an Indian politician, so he is biased against the system and probably exaggerates how bad it was.

Doc 6 is about a Jewish family leaving Russia. This shows that people also migrated to escape violence.

Overall, economic forces were the main cause of migration in this period.

How it scored

1/1thesis — A defensible claim with a reason (better jobs and wages). The reasoning is thin, but it answers the prompt and takes a position.
1/1context — The opening is general but relevant: it names industrialization spreading from Britain, labor demand, and cheaper steamship travel, and ties them to migration. It earns the point where the mid Asian-states essay does not. It gives several sentences on real developments and links each one to the topic, while that essay gives one generic phrase that explains nothing.
2/2doc-evidence — Docs 1, 3, 4 and 5 each support the wage argument, which meets the four-document threshold. Doc 2 is misread, since indenture contracts signed in famine were not a free choice like the Italians’ seasonal moves, but four supporting documents are enough.
0/1outside-evidence — Nothing specific appears beyond the documents. “The Industrial Revolution” and “steamships” are general and serve as context. No law, event or migrant stream outside the documents is named.
0/1sourcing — Doc 7 is dismissed as “biased” without explaining how the speaker’s purpose shapes the argument, and no other document is sourced.
0/1complexity — Doc 6 is mentioned but never weighed. The essay also treats indenture as free choice, missing the coercion that would have complicated its argument.

Where points die

Reading what you expect into a document instead of what it says. Students write that the Jesuits converted the Chinese emperor, or that the Great Wall kept the Manchus out, even when the document says the opposite. Read every document twice, once for content and once for its source line. Chinese emperors used Jesuit astronomy and cannon but never converted. A misread document cannot count toward the four you need for the second evidence point.

Turning a selective policy into a total one, such as “Japan cut itself off from the world” or “China rejected everything Western.” Tokugawa Japan banned Christianity and the Portuguese but kept trading with the Dutch at Dejima, the Chinese and Korea. The Qing kept Jesuit scientists while banning their preaching. The DBQ rewards you for explaining what a state accepted and what it refused, and why.

Assuming that reform or contact meant freedom or friendship. Peter the Great’s Westernization is read as Enlightenment liberty. Safavid policy is read as toleration, even when the document describes forced conversion. Ask what the ruler wanted. Peter wanted a stronger army and state, and serfdom got tighter under him. Shah Ismail’s Shia policy was forced uniformity that set Iran against its Sunni neighbors. Tie each document to the state’s goal, not to a modern value.

Sourcing by label: “The author is biased because he is Mughal” or “he probably exaggerates.” Name the audience, purpose, point of view or situation, then say what it changes about the evidence. A Dutch employee describing his own company’s humiliation is believable because he has no reason to invent it. Do this properly for two documents.

Writing contextualization as one phrase, then marching through the documents in numbered order. Spend three or four sentences on the situation before the prompt’s start date, with names and dates. Then build body paragraphs around claims and group documents under them. One paragraph might cover the land empires with Docs 2, 3, 4 and 6, and the next the island states with Docs 5 and 7.

Ignoring the document that cuts against your thesis, or tacking on one “however” sentence and hoping it earns complexity. The awkward document is your best route to the complexity point. Explain where and why your claim stops working, like the Dutch conquest of Banda, where no strong state existed. Then fold that limit into your thesis.

Score your own response

0 / 7

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.