On this page · 5 sections
The short-answer section is Section I, Part B: three questions in 40 minutes, worth 20 percent of your exam score. Each question has three parts labeled (a), (b), and (c), and each part is worth exactly one point, so nine points are available. There is no thesis point, no contextualization point, and no complexity point. A grader reads each box and asks a single question: did this student complete the task the verb demanded, using accurate and specific history?
The three questions are not interchangeable, and from May 2027 all three are required. Question 1 is built on one or more secondary sources, excerpts in which a historian makes an argument. Its three parts typically ask you to describe that argument, support it, then undermine it. Question 2 gives you a primary text source: a speech, a letter, a law, a diary entry. Question 3 gives you a non-text source, primary or secondary: a cartoon, a photograph, a map, a data table or graph, and a table compiled by a modern researcher is secondary evidence rather than primary. Each question focuses on a different period of the course. The old choice between two final questions with no stimulus is gone.
Scoring is binary inside each part, so partial credit does not exist there. A response that names a correct event but never connects it to the task earns zero, and so does a beautifully argued paragraph about the wrong decade. You type your answers in Bluebook, in three separate boxes, and graders score the content in the box where it appears. A brilliant answer to (b) typed into the (a) box is a gift to nobody. Length is not rewarded either: two to four sentences per part is the standard shape of a full-credit response. Aim to have all nine parts typed by minute 37, which leaves three minutes to reread.
The steps
- 1
Read the verb and the date range first
Before you read the stimulus, read the three tasks and mark two things in each: the command verb and the time boundary. APUSH is administered digitally, so highlight them with the annotation tool in Bluebook, or copy the verb and the date range onto the scratch paper you are issued.
Two verbs run this section. "Briefly describe" wants characteristics or features: what the thing was, what it did, who it affected. "Briefly explain" wants how or why, which means you must produce a because. Neither verb is satisfied by a name, so typing "the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890" and stopping earns zero anywhere in this section. Every box needs at least one complete sentence that performs the task.
An explain prompt answered with a description is the single most common way students lose points they already knew the history for.
The date range is equally load-bearing. If part (b) says "from 1865 to 1877," the Plessy v. Ferguson decision of 1896 is worth zero regardless of how well you write about it. Catch the scope words as well: ONE cause, ONE difference, ONE example. The exam asks for one, so give exactly one.
- 2
Read the source for its argument, then bring your own evidence
On Questions 1 and 2, the stimulus is there to be reasoned about, not mined for answers.
Read a secondary source for one thing: the historian's claim. What does this person say caused the outcome, or what does this person say it meant? Compress the excerpt to a single sentence in your head, something like "She argues Reconstruction collapsed because the North lost interest." Get the argument, not the topic.
For a primary source, ask who produced it, for whom, and what they wanted that audience to do. Those questions usually unlock the describe part.
Now the rule students break most often: the source is never enough. Every explain part requires outside evidence, meaning a specific event, law, group, or development that is not in the excerpt. Paraphrasing the historian back at the grader answers nothing. The stimulus tells you what to argue about, but your own knowledge of the period is what actually scores.
Do not quote the source at length. A short phrase in quotation marks is fine when it pins down the claim you are naming, but copying three lines burns typing time and earns nothing.
One format aside: some practice sets you will meet use an older two-historian version of Question 1, where you name a difference between two interpretations. If you get one, remember that the difference must be a difference in argument, not in subject matter.
- 3
Choose your evidence before you type a word
Spend 30 seconds picking evidence. The point turns on specificity, so run a fast test on each candidate: can you attach a proper noun and a rough date to it?
"Farmers were angry in the 1890s" fails, while "the Populist Party's 1892 Omaha Platform demanded free coinage of silver and government ownership of the railroads" passes. "There were protests against the Vietnam War" fails; "the 1968 Tet Offensive shattered official claims that the war was nearly won" passes.
Prefer evidence you can explain over evidence that merely sounds impressive, because a grader cannot award a point for a term you named but could not use. If your first idea is one you only half remember, drop it and take the second. There is no bonus for obscurity.
One caution: never hedge by listing three possible answers and hoping the grader finds the good one. Contradictory or scattershot responses can lose a point you would have earned with a single clear claim, so commit to one.
- 4
Answer in the first sentence, then prove it
Use the same three-move shape in every box: answer, evidence, link.
Sentence one answers the task directly and reuses the prompt's own language, so the grader sees the task completed before reading anything else. Suppose the prompt reads: Briefly explain ONE cause of the Great Depression. Your opening line is then obvious, and it is this: one cause of the Great Depression was the collapse of farm income during the 1920s.
Sentence two supplies the specific evidence: the act, the case, the battle, the number, the year.
Sentence three closes the loop and states the mechanism. Students skip this sentence constantly, and it is usually the one carrying the point. It should contain a connective like because, which meant, or therefore, and it should end by touching the exact wording of the task again.
Write in complete sentences, because bullet fragments and outline notes are not scored as responses.
- 5
Make the link do causal work
On explain parts, the grader is hunting for a stated relationship between your evidence and the claim, and naming the Homestead Act of 1862 is not an explanation of westward migration.
Here is what an explanation looks like. The Homestead Act let an adult citizen or head of household claim 160 acres of public land, but title came only after five years of living on the claim and improving it. That offer pulled hundreds of thousands of families onto the Plains.
A reliable trick: after you write your link sentence, reread it alone, without the sentences above it. If it still says how one thing produced another, you are finished; if it only restates that the thing existed, you have described rather than explained.
On support parts, where you are asked to explain how a development supports a historian's interpretation, your link must name the interpretation. Do not leave the grader to infer the connection: say outright that the event fits the argument because it demonstrates the mechanism that historian identified.
- 6
Argue against the source on the refute part
The hardest box on the SAQ is the one asking you to explain a development that undermines, refutes, or challenges the historian's argument. You are being asked to argue against the printed page, and students freeze because the excerpt looks authoritative. The excerpt is not evidence; it is an interpretation, and interpretations can be wrong.
Work it in three moves. First, name what the historian says produced the outcome. Second, produce a specific development that points to a different cause, a different timing, or a different group. Third, state in one sentence how your evidence cuts against that mechanism.
The third move is where the point lives, and "the Colfax Massacre undermines this argument" explains nothing. "This undermines the argument because Republican rule in Grant Parish was destroyed by local terror in 1873, years before Northern policy shifted" does the work.
Timing is your strongest refutation tool. If a historian blames cause X, and you can show the outcome was already underway before X happened, the mechanism breaks. Scope works too: show that the claim holds for one region or one group but not another. You are not required to prove the historian wrong, only to show one specific thing the argument does not account for.
- 7
Budget 13 minutes per question and defend the clock
Forty minutes divided by three is roughly 13 minutes each, and that includes reading. Set two checkpoints: at minute 13 you should be starting Question 2, and at minute 27 you should be starting your chosen question.
Do all three parts of a question before you move on. Parts (b) and (c) are often easier than (a), and abandoning a question mid-stream to polish an earlier one is how students hand back points.
If you are stuck on one part, write your best specific answer and move on. A blank box is a guaranteed zero, while a plausible answer with real evidence sometimes lands, so never let one hard part consume the time for two whole questions.
The choice between Question 3 and Question 4 should take five seconds. Skim both stems, pick the era where you can name three specific things immediately, and never switch after you have started typing.
Worked through
Here is a Question 1 in its current shape: one secondary source, one historian, and a (c) part that asks you to argue back. The excerpt below is a paraphrase written for this walkthrough and attributed to an invented Historian A, so it is not a quotation from any real scholar.
Historian A argues that Reconstruction failed chiefly because Northern commitment drained away. On this account, economic depression and party calculation pushed congressional Republicans to give up on federal enforcement in the South.
(a) Briefly describe Historian A's argument about why Reconstruction failed. (b) Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event or development from 1865 to 1877 that is not explicitly mentioned in the excerpt could be used to support Historian A's argument. (c) Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event or development from 1865 to 1877 that is not explicitly mentioned in the excerpt could be used to undermine Historian A's argument.
STEP 1, decode. Part (a) is describe, so state the argument clearly and say who the historian holds responsible. Parts (b) and (c) are explain, so each one needs a because, and each one needs outside evidence rather than a restatement of the excerpt. Everything must sit between 1865 and 1877.
STEP 2, compress the source. One sentence: A locates the cause of failure in Northern politics rather than in the South.
STEP 3, pick evidence. To support: the Compromise of 1877. To undermine: the Colfax Massacre of 1873. Both sit inside the window, both carry a name and a date, and I can state the mechanism of each without bluffing.
STEP 4, write.
(a) Historian A argues that Reconstruction failed because the North stopped sustaining it. The decisive actors in this reading are congressional Republicans and national party leaders, who lost the political will to keep enforcing Black civil and voting rights in the South. Depression and electoral calculation, not events inside the South, drove that retreat.
(b) The Compromise of 1877 supports Historian A. The disputed 1876 election between Rutherford B. Hayes and Samuel Tilden was resolved when Hayes took office and federal military protection for the remaining Republican state governments in Louisiana and South Carolina ended. Those governments fell to Democrats within weeks. This supports Historian A because national Republicans abandoned enforcement once the presidency was secured, which is exactly the Northern political retreat the argument describes.
(c) The Colfax Massacre of 1873 undermines Historian A. In Grant Parish, Louisiana, a white paramilitary force attacked Black freedmen and militia defending the courthouse after a disputed local election, killing an estimated 62 to 150 of them, many after they had surrendered. This cuts against Historian A because local terror destroyed Republican political organization in the parish in 1873. That collapse came four years before the Compromise, while federal enforcement still formally existed.
WHY THIS SCORES 3 OF 3. Part (a) states the argument and names who the historian blames, which is more than a label. Parts (b) and (c) each open by naming the evidence and its relationship to the argument, supply concrete detail with dates and places, and close by stating the mechanism. Part (c) does the hard thing: it does not merely assert that the massacre undermines the claim, it shows the timing problem the claim has.
Notice the hedge on the death toll. Estimates at Colfax run from roughly 62 to 150, and a student who writes "about 150 were killed" as flat fact has asserted the top of a contested range. The phrase "an estimated 62 to 150" costs three words and cannot be marked wrong. When a number is disputed, hedge it, because the point turns on the mechanism rather than the count.
Nothing here runs past four sentences, and nothing strays outside 1865 to 1877. Typing time: about 11 minutes.
Common mistakes
Restating the prompt instead of answering it. "Historian A makes a strong argument about Reconstruction, and there is a lot to say about this period" completes no task and scores zero, so your first sentence must contain the answer itself.
Answering from the stimulus alone. Paraphrasing the historian back at the grader, with no event, law, or group of your own, scores zero on an explain part, because outside evidence is the entire purpose of the question.
Backing down on the refute part. Writing that the evidence "kind of goes against" the argument, or explaining why the historian is right anyway, loses a point you could have taken. Name the historian's mechanism, then say plainly how your evidence contradicts it.
Using evidence outside the stated date range. The Dawes Act of 1887 cannot support a question bounded by 1865 to 1877, and the grader will not award the point for accurate history in the wrong window. Check the years before you commit.
Describing when the verb says explain. Writing that the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 banned combinations in restraint of trade describes it, while an explain prompt needs the next move: what the act did in practice and what followed from it. Leaving out the because is the most common single-point loss on this section.
Staying vague. "People were upset about taxes," "many Americans moved west," and "the government passed laws" all read as guesses, and every part needs at least one proper noun plus one date, number, or named policy.
Hedging with a list. Offering three candidate answers so one might be right can cost the point, especially when the options contradict each other. Choose one answer and defend it, which is different from hedging a disputed number, a move that remains safe and smart.
Treating it like an essay. There is no thesis point, no introduction point, and no conclusion point on an SAQ, so a five-sentence windup only burns minutes you need for Question 3. Two format rules matter here too: write in complete sentences rather than outline fragments, and put each answer in its own labeled box, because graders score the content where it appears.
Checklist
- Can you state, without looking, how many SAQs you must answer, how many minutes you have, and how many total points are on offer?
- Can you say what "briefly describe" and "briefly explain" each require, and name which one demands a causal sentence?
- Can you reduce a secondary-source excerpt to one sentence that captures the historian's argument rather than its topic?
- Can you name, for any explain part, one piece of outside evidence that is not mentioned anywhere in the stimulus?
- Can you produce, for any part, an answer sentence that reuses the prompt's own wording in the first line?
- Can you name three specific pieces of evidence, each with a proper noun and a date, for every period the exam might ask you about?
- Can you write a link sentence that stands alone and still explains how your evidence produced the outcome?
- Can you take a historian's argument and state one specific development that cuts against it, saying out loud how it breaks the mechanism?
- Can you finish all three parts of one SAQ in 13 minutes, typed, without an introduction?
- Can you decide in five seconds whether you are taking the Periods 1 to 5 question or the Periods 6 to 9 question?