Henry Clay of Kentucky delivered a speech to the House of Representatives in 1824 defending protective tariffs: 'We are the victims of the most fatal delusion... The prosperity of agriculture is inseparable from the prosperity of manufactures... The measure now before the House is recommended to it by its tendency to diversify and multiply the vocations, and thereby increase the productions of human labor—it gives work to the idle—it stimulates the exertion of existing industry—it excites enterprise—it distributes resources throughout the whole community.' Clay argued that manufactures, agriculture, and commerce formed an interdependent national economy.
Clay's speech most directly reflects which broader economic and political program of the Era of Good Feelings?
- AThe American System, which used protective tariffs, a national bank, and federally funded internal improvements to build an integrated national economy.Correct
- BThe Jacksonian economic program, which opposed protective tariffs and the national bank as instruments that favored wealthy elites over ordinary working Americans.
- CThe Jeffersonian agrarian vision, which distrusted manufacturing as a corrupting force and sought to preserve America as a republic of independent yeoman farmers.
- DThe free-trade philosophy of Southern planters, who wanted cheap British manufactured goods unburdened by protective tariff duties.
Why A is right
Clay's argument for protective tariffs as a means of stimulating domestic manufacturing, employment, and economic diversification is a core element of his American System—a comprehensive economic program that also included a national bank and federal funding for internal improvements (canals, roads) to integrate the national economy.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because Jacksonian Democrats opposed protective tariffs (the 1828 'Tariff of Abominations') and the national bank; Clay's American System was precisely the program Jackson opposed, making Clay and Jackson's economic philosophies antithetical.
- C
- Incorrect because Clay explicitly argues for manufacturing and industrial diversity, directly opposing Jefferson's agrarian vision that feared manufacturing would corrupt republican virtue; Clay and Jefferson represent opposed economic philosophies.
- D
- Incorrect because Southern planters were the primary opponents of protective tariffs, which raised prices on British manufactured goods; Clay's speech defends protective tariffs against free trade advocates, not alongside them.