Read the following description and answer the question.
The savings and loan crisis was one of the largest financial failures in modern American history. More than 1,000 savings and loan institutions failed, and the federal bailout ultimately cost taxpayers an estimated $125 to $175 billion. The crisis followed deregulation that allowed S&Ls to make riskier investments while their deposits remained federally insured. When many of those investments failed, the public bore the cost of the losses.
The savings and loan crisis of the late 1980s and early 1990s most directly reflected which broader historical pattern?
- AThe consequences of excessive regulation, which had prevented savings and loan institutions from making profitable investments until deregulation allowed them to compete
- BA deliberate fraud scheme organized by Reagan administration officials, who used deregulation to funnel insured deposits into real estate ventures for personal gain
- CThe unintended consequences of financial deregulation, where removing oversight of federally insured institutions created moral hazard and required costly government bailoutsCorrect
- DThe failure of Keynesian economic policies, which had encouraged excessive government intervention in financial markets and prevented market discipline from working
Why C is right
The S&L crisis exemplified moral hazard: federal deposit insurance protected depositors, so deregulation allowed S&L managers to take enormous risks without bearing the downside risk themselves. When risky real estate investments failed in the late 1980s, taxpayers bore the losses. This pattern — privatizing gains while socializing losses — would recur in the 2008 financial crisis.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- S&Ls had been profitable and stable under regulation before 1980s deregulation; the claim that regulation had prevented profitability misrepresents the historical record.
- B
- While individual fraud cases occurred, the crisis was systemic rather than the result of a centrally organized conspiracy; blaming Reagan officials personally goes beyond the historical evidence.
- D
- The S&L crisis was caused by deregulation, not Keynesian over-regulation; blaming Keynesian policies inverts the actual cause and represents a partisan mischaracterization.