In his 1963 "Letter from Birmingham Jail," Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. defended civil disobedience by arguing that there are two kinds of laws, just and unjust, and that an unjust law is one a majority imposes on a minority without binding itself to it. King's argument most directly drew on which philosophical tradition to justify breaking such laws?
- ASocial contract theory, holding that laws violating the democratic majority's 'general will' forfeit their binding moral force over citizens
- BUtilitarian ethics, holding that selective law-breaking is justified whenever the social benefits of ending segregation outweigh its costs
- CThe natural law tradition, holding that unjust human laws conflict with a higher moral law and so lack genuine authorityCorrect
- DMarxist revolutionary theory, holding that oppressed classes must overthrow unjust orders by whatever means prove effective in practice
Why C is right
In the Letter, King grounded his case in the natural law tradition, naming Augustine and Aquinas for the distinction between just and unjust laws. Natural law holds that human laws must conform to a higher moral or divine standard to be morally binding, and that laws violating that standard lack genuine authority. For civil disobedience itself King reached for Socrates and for the biblical refusal of Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego to obey Nebuchadnezzar. (Thoreau shaped King's thinking on civil disobedience, but King does not name him in this text.) King argued that Birmingham's segregation ordinances were unjust on these grounds and that moral responsibility required disobeying them openly, nonviolently, and with willingness to accept the legal consequences.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because King did not invoke Rousseau's general will theory; his argument turned on the content of laws (whether they conform to divine and natural law) rather than on their procedural legitimacy derived from majority will.
- B
- Incorrect because, although King did make consequentialist points about the harms of segregation, the tradition he specifically invoked in the Letter was the natural law distinction between just and unjust laws, not a utilitarian cost-benefit calculation.
- D
- Incorrect because King explicitly distinguished his approach from revolutionary violence; he drew on a tradition of nonviolent civil disobedience rather than Marxist revolutionary theory, repeatedly emphasizing nonviolence as both strategy and moral principle.