"The temperance movement of the 1830s and 1840s was among the largest reform movements in antebellum America. By 1836, the American Temperance Society claimed over a million members. Temperance advocates argued that alcohol consumption destroyed families, impoverished workers, and made men unable to fulfill their obligations as husbands, fathers, and citizens. The movement had its strongest support in evangelical Protestant communities of the North." — Antebellum reform history, 2008
A historian could best use this source to support which of the following arguments?
- AThe temperance movement had negligible popular support, remained confined to a small educated elite, and had no measurable effect on the heavy drinking patterns common among working-class and rural Americans of the period
- BThe temperance movement marked the decline of evangelical Protestant influence in antebellum America, as new secular and church-independent reform organizations displaced the older tradition of faith-based social activism
- CThe temperance movement reflected middle-class Protestant anxieties about social order, aiming to discipline the behavior of immigrant and working-class men amid rapid urbanization and immigrationCorrect
- DThe temperance movement was uniquely focused on legal prohibition from its earliest years and, from the outset, organized chiefly to win constitutional amendments banning the production and sale of alcohol nationwide
Why C is right
Historians have analyzed the temperance movement as reflecting multiple social anxieties of antebellum America: the disruption of traditional community bonds by urbanization and immigration, middle-class anxieties about social order, and Protestant beliefs about moral discipline and self-control. By targeting alcohol as the source of poverty, family breakdown, and civic incapacity, temperance advocates implicitly targeted the cultural practices of Irish Catholic immigrants and working-class men whose drinking patterns differed from middle-class Protestant norms.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage explicitly states the movement claimed over a million members by 1836 — representing mass popular support, not elite marginality.
- B
- Incorrect because the temperance movement was explicitly grounded in evangelical Protestant culture — the passage states its 'strongest support' was in 'evangelical Protestant communities'; it represented the flourishing, not the decline, of evangelical social activism.
- D
- Incorrect because the early temperance movement of the 1830s was primarily focused on moral suasion and voluntary pledges, not legal prohibition; legal prohibition (Maine Law, 1851) came later, and the constitutional amendment (18th Amendment) did not come until 1919.