The table describes four hypothetical federal laws, each passed under Congress's commerce clause power.
| Hypothetical law | Activity regulated | Is the activity commercial or economic? | Congressional findings on interstate effects |
|---|---|---|---|
| Act W | Sale of handguns by licensed dealers to buyers in other states | Yes | Extensive |
| Act X | Possession of a knife within 500 feet of a public park | No | None |
| Act Y | Wheat grown for a farmer's own use, counted toward national crop quotas | Yes, as part of a national market scheme | Extensive |
| Act Z | Wages and hours of workers at factories that ship goods to other states | Yes | Extensive |
Based on the table and the Supreme Court's reasoning in United States v. Lopez (1995), which law is most likely to be struck down as exceeding Congress's commerce clause power?
- AAct W, because selling firearms is a state police-power matter even when the sales cross state lines
- BAct X, because possessing a knife near a park is not economic activity and Congress made no findings linking it to interstate commerceCorrect
- CAct Y, because wheat grown for a farmer's own use never enters the market and so cannot be regulated as commerce
- DAct Z, because the Tenth Amendment reserves to the states the power to set wages and hours for factory workers
Why B is right
In United States v. Lopez (1995), the Court struck down the Gun-Free School Zones Act because possessing a gun near a school is not an economic activity, is not part of a larger scheme regulating economic activity, and Congress had made no findings showing a substantial effect on interstate commerce. In the table, only Act X matches that profile: it regulates mere possession of a weapon near a public place (the table marks it non-economic) and has no congressional findings on interstate effects. Acts W, Y, and Z each regulate commercial or economic activity backed by extensive findings, so they fall within the commerce power as the Court has interpreted it.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Act W regulates interstate sales by licensed dealers, which the table marks as commercial with extensive findings; selling goods across state lines is the core of interstate commerce, so Lopez's reasoning does not threaten it.
- C
- This misreads the table and confuses Act Y with a purely local activity; under Wickard v. Filburn (1942), home-grown wheat that is part of a national market scheme can be regulated because its aggregate effect on interstate commerce is substantial, and Lopez distinguished rather than overruled Wickard.
- D
- Act Z regulates wages and hours of workers producing goods for interstate shipment, an economic activity Congress may regulate (as in United States v. Darby, 1941); the Tenth Amendment does not bar such regulation of private factories, and the table shows extensive findings.