- AThe data are most consistent with elite theory, because proposals backed by economic elites passed at similar rates whether or not median-income citizens agreed, while proposals backed only by median-income citizens rarely passedCorrect
- BThe data are most consistent with pluralism, because proposals with several different groups of supporters were adopted, showing that power is spread among many competing groups
- CThe data are most consistent with participatory democracy, because proposals favored by both economic elites and median-income citizens had the highest adoption rate
- DThe data are most consistent with hyperpluralism, because most proposals in every category failed, showing that competing groups block one another
Why A is right
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Pluralism predicts that many groups can win on the issues they care about. In the table, median-income citizens rarely got their way against elite opposition (12% adopted), so the data do not show power spread among competing groups.
- C
- Proposals favored by both groups did pass most often (63%), but proposals favored only by elites passed at nearly the same rate (58%). Citizen support added little, so the data do not support participatory democracy, which holds that broad public participation drives outcomes.
- D
- The claim misreads the table. Most elite-favored proposals passed (58% and 63%), so it is false that most proposals in every category failed. The pattern shows one group's preferences winning, not gridlock among many groups.