- AAll government classifications are subject to strict scrutiny, requiring that the government prove a compelling interest for any law that treats groups differently
- BEconomic classifications are subject to strict scrutiny because they affect property rights; social classifications receive rational basis review
- COnly classifications against historically oppressed groups receive heightened scrutiny; all other classifications receive rational basis review
- DRace and national origin classifications are subject to strict scrutiny; gender to intermediate scrutiny; most other classifications to rational basis reviewCorrect
Why D is right
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because applying strict scrutiny to all classifications would prevent government from making virtually any distinctions between groups; the tiered approach recognizes different degrees of constitutional concern.
- B
- Incorrect because economic regulations typically receive rational basis review — the most deferential standard; strict scrutiny applies to race and fundamental rights, not economic regulations.
- C
- Incorrect because the determination of which scrutiny level applies is based on the type of classification (suspect vs. quasi-suspect vs. other), not purely on whether the targeted group has been 'historically oppressed.'