Read the following practice passage.
Congress passes a law offering states money to repair highways and bridges. To receive the full amount, each state must adopt a statewide speed limit no higher than a level Congress sets. A state that refuses may keep its own speed limit, but it loses a share of its federal transportation funds. Several governors object that Congress is using money to accomplish what it could not order directly, while supporters reply that states remain free to turn the money down. Within two years, nearly every state has changed its law to meet the condition.
The scenario described in the passage best illustrates which of the following?
- AFiscal federalism, in which national grant conditions are used to shape state policy choicesCorrect
- BConcurrent powers, in which both levels of government separately enact and enforce their own traffic laws
- CAn unfunded mandate, in which Congress directly orders states to act without supplying any money
- DDual federalism, in which national and state governments act only within separate spheres
Why A is right
In the passage, Congress gives states transportation money only if they adopt its speed limit, and states that refuse lose part of the funds. The governors' complaint, that Congress is using money to get what it could not order directly, and the result, that nearly every state complies, show the national government shaping state policy through conditions on grants. That is fiscal federalism: the financial relationships between levels of government, especially federal grants and the conditions attached to them.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Concurrent powers are powers both levels hold independently, such as taxing. In the passage, the states change their speed limits because of a federal funding condition. They are not acting on their own separate authority.
- C
- An unfunded mandate requires states to act without giving them federal money. In the passage, Congress offers money and states may turn it down, which makes it a conditional grant and not a mandate.
- D
- Dual federalism keeps national and state governments in separate spheres. The passage shows the opposite: federal money reaching into an area of state policy, highway speed limits, and changing it.