The table shows hypothetical data on four city ordinances regulating the slaughter of animals. Each ordinance is challenged by a religious group whose ceremonies include animal sacrifice.
| Ordinance | Year enacted | Activity covered | Secular exemptions written into the law | Public support (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P | 1785 | Slaughter performed as part of a religious ceremony | 0 | 81 |
| Q | 2015 | All slaughter of animals within city limits | 0 | 48 |
| R | 1990 | All slaughter of animals within city limits | 5 | 74 |
| S | 1960 | All slaughter of animals within city limits | 1 | 66 |
Based on the table and the standard the Supreme Court applied in Employment Division v. Smith (1990), which ordinance could the city most likely enforce against the religious group without granting it a religious exemption?
- AOrdinance P, enacted in 1785 and backed by 81 percent of residents
- BOrdinance Q, enacted in 2015 and supported by 48 percent of residentsCorrect
- COrdinance R, enacted in 1990 and backed by 74 percent of residents
- DOrdinance S, enacted in 1960 and backed by 66 percent of residents
Why B is right
Under Employment Division v. Smith (1990), a law that burdens religious practice can be enforced without a religious exemption if it is neutral and generally applicable. In the table, only Ordinance Q both covers all slaughter (it does not single out religious ceremonies) and has no secular exemptions. Ordinance P covers only slaughter performed as part of a religious ceremony, so it targets religion and is not neutral (compare Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye v. Hialeah, 1993). Ordinances R and S exempt some secular slaughter but not religious slaughter, so they are not generally applicable and would face strict scrutiny. Public support and the year a law was enacted do not matter under this test.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Misreads the table by focusing on Ordinance P's high public support and early enactment date. Its 'Activity covered' column shows it reaches only slaughter performed in religious ceremonies, so it targets religion and is not neutral under Smith.
- C
- Notices that Ordinance R covers all slaughter and has strong public support, but misses its 5 secular exemptions. A law that exempts comparable secular conduct while refusing religious exemptions is not generally applicable.
- D
- Treats a single secular exemption as too small to matter. Even one secular exemption means Ordinance S does not apply to everyone equally, so it is not generally applicable and the Smith rule does not protect it.