The Eighth Amendment bans excessive bail, excessive fines, and cruel and unusual punishments. The Court applied the cruel and unusual punishments ban to the states in Robinson v. California (1962) and the excessive fines ban in Timbs v. Indiana (2019). It has assumed, but never directly held, that the excessive bail ban binds the states as well.
Why it matters
It is the Bill of Rights' main limit on what government can do to a person who has been charged or convicted, covering bail before trial and fines and sentences as punishment. Because the Court reads its punishment clause by evolving standards of decency, its meaning can change as state laws and public values change.
How the exam tests it
Questions may test the clauses that are not about prison or execution. In Timbs v. Indiana (2019), Indiana seized Tyson Timbs's $42,000 Land Rover after a drug sale that carried a maximum fine of $10,000. The Court held that the Excessive Fines Clause binds the states, so a forfeiture far out of proportion to the offense can be challenged. If a question asks which amendment limits a state's fines or forfeitures, pick the Eighth.
Don’t confuse it with
Students confuse the Eighth Amendment with the Fifth and Sixth, but those protect rights during investigation and trial, such as silence and counsel, while the Eighth limits bail, fines and the punishment itself.