The table shows hypothetical data on four defamation lawsuits brought by public officials against newspapers.
| Claim | Plaintiff | Was the statement false? | Publisher's conduct before printing | Plaintiff's reported loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| W | City mayor | Yes | Checked two sources, both of which turned out to be mistaken | $250,000 |
| X | State senator | Yes | Was told by the only eyewitness that the claim was untrue, then printed it unchanged | $40,000 |
| Y | Governor | No | Ran the story to hurt the governor's reelection campaign | $90,000 |
| Z | County sheriff | Yes | Editor openly despised the sheriff; relied on a typo in an official court record | $60,000 |
Based on the table, which claim would most likely succeed under the standard the Supreme Court established in New York Times v. Sullivan (1964)?
- AClaim W, because the mayor reported the largest loss of the four
- BClaim X onlyCorrect
- CClaim Y, because the publisher acted to hurt the governor
- DClaim Z, because the editor showed personal hostility to the sheriff
Why B is right
New York Times v. Sullivan requires a public official suing for defamation to prove actual malice: the publisher knew the statement was false or printed it with reckless disregard for whether it was false. In the table, only Claim X shows this. The publisher was told by the only eyewitness that the claim was untrue and printed it anyway, which is reckless disregard at the least. Claim W was an honest error despite checking sources. Claim Y was true. Claim Z shows personal hostility but reasonable reliance on an official record. A large reported loss (Claim W) does not satisfy the fault standard either.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Misreads the loss column as decisive. Actual malice is about the publisher's state of mind, not the size of the harm. Claim W's publisher checked two sources and believed the story, so the error was an honest mistake, not knowing falsity or reckless disregard.
- C
- The table shows Claim Y's statement was true. A true statement cannot be defamatory, and a motive to harm the official is not actual malice in the Sullivan sense.
- D
- Treats personal dislike as actual malice. Ill will or spite does not meet the Sullivan standard. Claim Z's editor relied on an official court record, so the publisher had no knowledge of falsity and did not recklessly disregard the truth.