Skip to content
AP U.S. Government and Politics · Civil Liberties and Civil Rights

Barron v baltimore

Barron v baltimore appears in 4 reviewed AP U.S. Government and Politics questions and sits in Civil Liberties and Civil Rights. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Barron v. Baltimore (1833) held that the Bill of Rights limits only the national government, not the states. John Barron claimed Baltimore ruined his wharf without paying him, but Chief Justice John Marshall ruled the Fifth Amendment's takings clause did not apply to a city.

Why it matters

Barron is the starting point for incorporation. Because of it, states could ignore the Bill of Rights until the Fourteenth Amendment (1868) gave the Court a tool to apply those rights to them.

How the exam tests it

Questions use Barron to set up selective incorporation. You need to explain that the Court later applied rights to the states one at a time through the Due Process Clause, not all at once.

Don’t confuse it with

Students confuse Barron with incorporation cases like Gitlow v. New York (1925), but Barron said the Bill of Rights did not bind states, while Gitlow was the first case to apply a First Amendment right, free speech, to the states.

Barron v baltimore in real questions

Example 1Harder
The doctrine of 'selective incorporation' holds that
  1. Athe Supreme Court applies provisions of the Bill of Rights to the states case-by-case under the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause, incorporating only rights fundamental to ordered libertyCorrect
  2. Bthe entire Bill of Rights applies to the states all at once, because the Fourteenth Amendment's Privileges or Immunities Clause was understood to incorporate every federal right against the state governments
  3. Cstate constitutions automatically absorb federal Bill of Rights provisions whenever they contain identical or closely similar language, so no Supreme Court ruling is ever needed to bind the states
  4. DCongress chooses which specific Bill of Rights provisions to apply to the states by enacting legislation under Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment, deciding case-by-case through democratic deliberation

Why A is right

After Barron v. Baltimore (1833) held the Bill of Rights applied only to the federal government, the Fourteenth Amendment's ratification (1868) raised the question of whether it incorporated the Bill of Rights against states. The Court rejected total incorporation (Justice Hugo Black's view that all of the Bill of Rights applies to states) and instead developed selective incorporation: through the Due Process Clause, the Court incorporates specific provisions case-by-case when a right is fundamental to ordered liberty. Today, nearly all Bill of Rights provisions have been incorporated, but the method remains selective and case-by-case rather than wholesale.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because total incorporation — applying all Bill of Rights provisions to states at once — was championed by Justice Hugo Black but never adopted by the Court majority; the Court has applied selective incorporation, not total incorporation, since the 1920s-30s.
C
Incorrect because the incorporation question is a federal constitutional matter determined by the Supreme Court; identical state constitutional language does not automatically incorporate federal Bill of Rights protections; the Court's case-by-case analysis is required.
D
Incorrect because selective incorporation is a judicial, not legislative, doctrine; Congress's Section 5 enforcement power allows it to enforce existing incorporated rights, not to selectively decide which rights to incorporate; that determination belongs to the Court.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Civil Liberties and Civil Rights.