A bag contains 4 red and 6 blue marbles. The Law of Total Probability states P(red on 2nd draw) = P(red 2nd | red 1st)×P(red 1st) + P(red 2nd | blue 1st)×P(blue 1st). If draws are WITHOUT replacement, what is P(red on the 2nd draw)?
- A3/10
- B4/10Correct
- C16/90
- D6/45
Why B is right
Using the Law of Total Probability: P(red 2nd) = P(red 2nd|red 1st)×P(red 1st) + P(red 2nd|blue 1st)×P(blue 1st) = (3/9)(4/10) + (4/9)(6/10) = 12/90 + 24/90 = 36/90 = 4/10 = 0.40. By symmetry, the probability of drawing red on any draw equals 4/10, the original proportion.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- 3/10 would be P(red on 2nd | red on 1st), the conditional probability given the first was red. This is not the unconditional probability for the 2nd draw.
- C
- 16/90 = P(red 1st)×P(red 2nd|red 1st) = (4/10)×(3/9) = 12/90, which is only one branch of the Law of Total Probability tree, not the complete calculation.
- D
- 6/45 is not a correct calculation from these values.
A game consists of drawing two cards without replacement from a deck containing 3 red cards and 7 blue cards. You win $10 if both cards are red and lose $3 otherwise. What is the expected value of your net gain?
- A$10 * (1/2) - $3 * (1/2) = $3.50
- B$10 * (3/10)(2/9) + $3 * (7/10)(6/9) = $2.07
- C$10 * (3/10)(3/10) - $3 * (1 - (3/10)(3/10)) = -$1.83
- D$10 * (3/10)(2/9) - $3 * (1 - (3/10)(2/9)) = -$1.13Correct
Why D is right
P(both red) = (3/10)(2/9) = 6/90 = 1/15 ≈ 0.0667. P(not both red) = 1 - 1/15 = 14/15 ≈ 0.9333. E(gain) = (1/15)($10) + (14/15)(-$3) = $0.667 - $2.80 = -$2.133. The calculation in the answer choice shows: 10(6/90) - 3(84/90) = 60/90 - 252/90 = -192/90 = -$2.13. On average, the player loses about $2.13 per game.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. This assumes a 50/50 chance of winning, which is not the case. The probability of drawing two red cards from 3 red out of 10 is much less than 50%.
- B
- Incorrect. This adds $3 instead of subtracting it for the losing outcome. The player loses $3 when both cards are not red, so the second term should be negative.
- C
- Incorrect. This uses (3/10)(3/10) = 9/100, which assumes sampling with replacement. Since cards are drawn without replacement, the probability of the second card being red changes after the first draw.