Skip to content
AP Statistics · Probability, Random Variables, and Probability Distributions

Without replacement

Without replacement appears in 7 reviewed AP Statistics questions and sits in Probability, Random Variables, and Probability Distributions. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Without replacement is tested

Example 1Harder
A bag contains 4 red and 6 blue marbles. The Law of Total Probability states P(red on 2nd draw) = P(red 2nd | red 1st)×P(red 1st) + P(red 2nd | blue 1st)×P(blue 1st). If draws are WITHOUT replacement, what is P(red on the 2nd draw)?
  1. A3/10
  2. B4/10Correct
  3. C16/90
  4. D6/45

Why B is right

Using the Law of Total Probability: P(red 2nd) = P(red 2nd|red 1st)×P(red 1st) + P(red 2nd|blue 1st)×P(blue 1st) = (3/9)(4/10) + (4/9)(6/10) = 12/90 + 24/90 = 36/90 = 4/10 = 0.40. By symmetry, the probability of drawing red on any draw equals 4/10, the original proportion.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
3/10 would be P(red on 2nd | red on 1st), the conditional probability given the first was red. This is not the unconditional probability for the 2nd draw.
C
16/90 = P(red 1st)×P(red 2nd|red 1st) = (4/10)×(3/9) = 12/90, which is only one branch of the Law of Total Probability tree, not the complete calculation.
D
6/45 is not a correct calculation from these values.
Example 2Harder
A game consists of drawing two cards without replacement from a deck containing 3 red cards and 7 blue cards. You win $10 if both cards are red and lose $3 otherwise. What is the expected value of your net gain?
  1. A$10 * (1/2) - $3 * (1/2) = $3.50
  2. B$10 * (3/10)(2/9) + $3 * (7/10)(6/9) = $2.07
  3. C$10 * (3/10)(3/10) - $3 * (1 - (3/10)(3/10)) = -$1.83
  4. D$10 * (3/10)(2/9) - $3 * (1 - (3/10)(2/9)) = -$1.13Correct

Why D is right

P(both red) = (3/10)(2/9) = 6/90 = 1/15 ≈ 0.0667. P(not both red) = 1 - 1/15 = 14/15 ≈ 0.9333. E(gain) = (1/15)($10) + (14/15)(-$3) = $0.667 - $2.80 = -$2.133. The calculation in the answer choice shows: 10(6/90) - 3(84/90) = 60/90 - 252/90 = -192/90 = -$2.13. On average, the player loses about $2.13 per game.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect. This assumes a 50/50 chance of winning, which is not the case. The probability of drawing two red cards from 3 red out of 10 is much less than 50%.
B
Incorrect. This adds $3 instead of subtracting it for the losing outcome. The player loses $3 when both cards are not red, so the second term should be negative.
C
Incorrect. This uses (3/10)(3/10) = 9/100, which assumes sampling with replacement. Since cards are drawn without replacement, the probability of the second card being red changes after the first draw.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Probability, Random Variables, and Probability Distributions.