A newspaper runs an online poll asking: 'Do you support the city's controversial new transit plan? Yes or No.' Of the 2,300 people who responded, 78% said 'No.' What is the PRIMARY reason why this result should NOT be used to conclude that 78% of city residents oppose the transit plan?
- AThe question asks only for a yes/no answer, which introduces response bias by forcing residents with mixed views to choose a side.
- BThe sample size of 2,300 is too small to represent the city.
- CThe poll should have used a 5-point Likert scale instead of a yes/no format, which would reduce nonresponse bias.
- DVoluntary response bias: people with strong opinions are more likely to answer an online poll.Correct
Why D is right
An online poll with open participation suffers from voluntary response bias: people who respond are self-selected and tend to have stronger opinions (especially negative ones) than the general population. The 78% 'No' result is likely an overestimate of opposition in the full city population because strong opponents are more motivated to respond.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because a yes/no format is a valid question structure. Response bias from question wording would apply if the question were leading, but here the question simply asks for a position. The bias comes from who responds, not from the answer format.
- B
- Incorrect because 2,300 is actually a large sample by statistical standards. The problem is not sample size but the self-selection of respondents, which creates bias regardless of sample size.
- C
- Incorrect because using a Likert scale would not address the fundamental problem of voluntary response bias. The issue is who chooses to respond, not the response format.