A distribution of final exam scores has mean 72, median 75, and standard deviation 10. A student who scored 92 wants to know how unusual their score is. Which approach is most informative?
- ACompute the range: 92 − 0 = 92, showing it is toward the high end.
- BCompare 92 to the median: the student scored 17 points above the median.
- CNote that 92 is in the top 10% because it exceeds 90.
- DCompute the z-score: (92 − 72)/10 = 2.0.Correct
Why D is right
The z-score (92 − 72)/10 = 2.0 means the score is 2 standard deviations above the mean, a standardized measure of how unusual it is relative to the distribution's spread. A z-score of 2.0 places the student at roughly the 97.7th percentile, which is clearly unusual.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The range of 92 − 0 is meaningless here. The lowest possible score would be the actual minimum of the dataset, and the range doesn't indicate how unusual a particular score is.
- B
- The raw difference from the median (17 points) doesn't account for the spread of the distribution. Without knowing the SD, we can't judge how unusual 17 points above the median is.
- C
- Claiming top 10% requires knowledge of the actual percentile, which depends on the full distribution. Without probability calculations, we cannot simply conclude '92 > 90 means top 10%.'