A clinical trial for a weight loss drug includes only men aged 30-50 from one hospital. The results show the drug is effective. A doctor at another hospital wants to prescribe it to a 65-year-old woman. Why should the doctor be cautious?
- AThe trial's narrow inclusion criteria (men aged 30-50) limit generalizability; the drug's effectiveness and safety may differ for women and older patientsCorrect
- BThe drug was only tested at one dosage level
- CThe clinical trial was not double-blind
- DClinical trials always produce unreliable results
Why A is right
The trial studied a specific subpopulation (men aged 30-50 from one hospital). The drug's effects may differ by sex, age, and other factors not represented in the trial. Prescribing to a 65-year-old woman extends beyond the trial's scope of inference, so caution is warranted.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the number of dosage levels is not mentioned and is not the primary concern; the issue is the limited study population.
- C
- Incorrect because the blinding status of the trial is not mentioned and is not the primary reason for caution in this context.
- D
- Incorrect because clinical trials are the gold standard for evaluating medical treatments; the concern here is generalizability, not reliability.
A researcher conducts a study with random assignment and finds a statistically significant result (p = 0.02). The experiment used a random sample from the population of interest. Which of the following conclusions is supported by this study?
- AAn association exists in the population but the causal direction cannot be determined
- BThe result is practically significant and has important real-world implications
- CA causal relationship can be inferred, and the result can be generalized to the population from which the sample was drawnCorrect
- DA causal relationship exists in the sample but cannot be generalized to the population
Why C is right
This study has both random assignment (enabling causal inference) and random sampling (enabling generalization to the population). With both design features present, the researcher can conclude that the causal relationship observed in the study likely holds in the broader population from which the sample was drawn.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because random assignment does allow causal inference; the limitation described here applies to observational studies.
- B
- Incorrect because statistical significance (p = 0.02) does not automatically imply practical significance; the effect size and context must be considered separately.
- D
- Incorrect because random sampling does allow generalization to the population; the result is not limited to just the sample.