A school district's nutrition coordinator thinks that more than 30 percent of the district's students skip breakfast on school days. To investigate, she selects a random sample of 400 students from the district, and 136 of them (p-hat = 0.34) report skipping breakfast on school days. She tests H0: p = 0.30 against Ha: p > 0.30, where p is the proportion of all students in the district who skip breakfast on school days. The test produces a p-value of about 0.040. Which of the following is a correct interpretation of this p-value?
- AThere is about a 0.960 probability that more than 30% of all students in the district skip breakfast on school days.
- BAssuming 30% of all students in the district skip breakfast, there is about a 0.040 probability of getting a sample proportion of 0.34 or greater in a random sample of 400 students.Correct
- CThere is about a 0.040 probability that exactly 30% of all students in the district skip breakfast on school days.
- DAssuming more than 30% of all students in the district skip breakfast, there is about a 0.040 probability of getting a sample proportion of 0.34 or greater.
Why B is right
A p-value is the probability of getting a sample result at least as extreme as the one observed, in the direction of Ha, calculated on the assumption that the null hypothesis is true. Here SE = sqrt(0.30(0.70)/400) = sqrt(0.000525) ≈ 0.0229, so z = (0.34 - 0.30)/0.0229 ≈ 1.75, and P(Z ≥ 1.75) ≈ 0.040. Choice B states this correctly: it assumes p = 0.30 and gives the probability of a sample proportion of 0.34 or more in a random sample of 400.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Takes 1 minus the p-value to be the probability that Ha is true. Neither 0.040 nor 0.960 is a probability that a hypothesis is true or false.
- C
- Treats the p-value as the probability that the null hypothesis is true. The p-value is calculated assuming H0 is true, so it cannot be the probability that H0 is true.
- D
- Assumes the alternative hypothesis instead of the null hypothesis. A p-value is always calculated under H0 (p = 0.30), not under Ha.