A teacher tells students: 'If you flip a coin 1,000 times, you'll get almost exactly 500 heads.' A statistician disagrees. Which of the following BEST captures the correct statistical understanding?
- ABoth are wrong — probability is unpredictable and heads count could be anywhere from 0 to 1,000.
- BThe teacher is right — with 1,000 flips, you always get exactly 500 heads.
- CThe teacher is right only if the coin is perfectly fair to 10 decimal places.
- DThe statistician is right — the Law of Large Numbers says the PROPORTION of heads converges to 0.5, but the actual NUMBER of heads will likely deviate from 500 by some amount (typically by about 16 heads in either direction).Correct
Why D is right
The Law of Large Numbers says the PROPORTION of heads converges to 0.5, not that the count is exactly 500. The expected count of heads is 500, but the standard deviation is sqrt(n*p*(1-p)) = sqrt(250) ≈ 15.8. So the count will typically deviate from 500 by about 16 in either direction. The PROPORTION (count/1000) converges to 0.5, but the absolute count has variability.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because probability does not make all outcomes equally likely in this context. By the CLT and LLN, heads count concentrates around 500 with decreasing relative variability as n grows. Outcomes far from 500 are extremely rare.
- B
- Incorrect because even a perfectly fair coin will produce a count that varies around 500. Getting exactly 500 heads in 1,000 flips has probability C(1000,500)*(0.5)^1000 ≈ 0.025 — less than 3% chance.
- C
- Incorrect because the LLN and CLT apply to any fair coin (probability exactly 0.5), and the convergence is probabilistic, not dependent on measurement precision of the fairness.