A researcher studying the effect of sleep on athletic performance uses a matched pairs design. Each athlete performs a physical test after 6 hours of sleep and then repeats the same test after 8 hours of sleep, with the order randomized. Why is the order of treatments randomized?
- ATo allow athletes to improve their performance between tests.
- BTo satisfy the independence condition required before running a matched pairs t-test.
- CTo ensure that each athlete gets the same number of hours of sleep overall across both tests.
- DTo balance practice and carryover effects across the two sleep conditions.Correct
Why D is right
Randomizing the order in a matched pairs (crossover) design controls for carryover effects (e.g., learning the test, muscle fatigue) and order effects (e.g., always having more energy at first). By randomly assigning half the athletes to do 6-hour sleep first and the other half to do 8-hour sleep first, these effects are balanced across the two conditions.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Allowing athletes to improve between tests would be a confound, not a goal. Randomizing order helps reveal whether such improvement (practice effect) is influencing results.
- B
- Independence in the matched pairs t-test refers to the differences being independent, not to the order of treatments. The order randomization serves a different purpose.
- C
- Total sleep hours are not the concern here. The total sleep would actually vary by design (some get 6 first, some get 8 first). The concern is about systematic advantages of doing one condition before the other.
A researcher conducts a study to determine whether background music affects reading comprehension. She recruits 40 volunteers and has each person take two reading tests: one with music and one in silence. The order of the conditions is randomly assigned. This is an example of:
- AA matched pairs (repeated measures) designCorrect
- BA completely randomized design with two treatment groups
- CA stratified experiment blocking on reading ability
- DAn observational study comparing two groups of readers
Why A is right
This is a matched pairs design because each subject experiences both conditions (music and silence), serving as their own control. By comparing each person's performance under both conditions, individual differences (reading ability, motivation) are controlled for. The random assignment of order prevents order effects.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because a completely randomized design would assign each person to only one condition, not have everyone experience both.
- C
- Incorrect because there is no blocking on reading ability; instead, each person acts as their own control, which is the matched pairs approach.
- D
- Incorrect because the researcher imposed the conditions (music vs. silence), making this an experiment, not an observational study.
In a matched-pairs experiment, 20 subjects each receive both a caffeine pill and a placebo on separate days (in random order). The researcher records reaction time (milliseconds) for each condition. After computing the differences (caffeine minus placebo) for each subject, the researcher finds a mean difference of -15 ms with a standard deviation of 20 ms. The null hypothesis is that caffeine has no effect (mean difference = 0). Which procedure should be used?
- ATwo-proportion z-test comparing proportions who improved under each condition.
- BTwo-sample t-test using the 20 caffeine times and 20 placebo times as independent groups.
- COne-sample t-test on the 20 differences, with H0: μ_d = 0.Correct
- DChi-square goodness of fit test for reaction time distributions.
Why C is right
A matched-pairs design produces one difference score per subject. The appropriate test is a one-sample t-test applied to the n = 20 difference scores, testing H0: μ_d = 0. The t-statistic would be t = (x-bar_d - 0)/(s_d/sqrt(n)) = -15/(20/sqrt(20)) = -15/4.47 ≈ -3.35.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the data are continuous (reaction times in milliseconds), not proportions. A two-proportion z-test requires categorical outcomes.
- B
- Incorrect because the two sets of observations are not independent — each person provides both measurements. A two-sample t-test assumes independence between groups, which is violated in a matched-pairs design.
- D
- Incorrect because a chi-square goodness of fit test assesses whether observed categorical frequencies match expected frequencies. Continuous reaction time data analyzed in a matched-pairs design call for a t-test on differences.