A researcher studying the effect of sleep on athletic performance uses a matched pairs design. Each athlete performs a physical test after 6 hours of sleep and then repeats the same test after 8 hours of sleep, with the order randomized. Why is the order of treatments randomized?
- ATo allow athletes to improve their performance between tests.
- BTo satisfy the independence condition required before running a matched pairs t-test.
- CTo ensure that each athlete gets the same number of hours of sleep overall across both tests.
- DTo balance practice and carryover effects across the two sleep conditions.Correct
Why D is right
Randomizing the order in a matched pairs (crossover) design controls for carryover effects (e.g., learning the test, muscle fatigue) and order effects (e.g., always having more energy at first). By randomly assigning half the athletes to do 6-hour sleep first and the other half to do 8-hour sleep first, these effects are balanced across the two conditions.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Allowing athletes to improve between tests would be a confound, not a goal. Randomizing order helps reveal whether such improvement (practice effect) is influencing results.
- B
- Independence in the matched pairs t-test refers to the differences being independent, not to the order of treatments. The order randomization serves a different purpose.
- C
- Total sleep hours are not the concern here. The total sleep would actually vary by design (some get 6 first, some get 8 first). The concern is about systematic advantages of doing one condition before the other.