A frequency table shows the following distribution of letter grades in a statistics class: A (5 students), B (12 students), C (8 students), D (3 students), F (2 students). A student creates a bar chart with the bars ordered A, B, C, D, F. Another student creates a pie chart of the same data. Which display is more appropriate and why?
- AThe bar chart is more appropriate because it preserves the natural ordering of grades and makes comparisons between categories easierCorrect
- BBoth displays are equally appropriate; the choice is purely aesthetic
- CNeither display is appropriate because the data are quantitative
- DThe pie chart is more appropriate because it shows proportions of a whole
Why A is right
Letter grades are ordinal categorical data with a natural ordering. A bar chart preserves this order and makes it easy to compare the frequencies of adjacent categories. While a pie chart can also display categorical data, bar charts are generally preferred for comparing categories, especially when order matters.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the natural ordering of grades and the ease of comparison make the bar chart more appropriate than a pie chart for this context.
- C
- Incorrect because letter grades are categorical (ordinal) data, and both bar charts and pie charts are appropriate displays for categorical data.
- D
- Incorrect because while pie charts do show proportions, they make it difficult to compare similar-sized categories and do not naturally convey the ordering of letter grades.