A town's public works department wants to estimate the proportion p of its 5,000 streetlights that are burned out. An inspector selects a simple random sample of 200 streetlights and finds that 18 of them are burned out, so p-hat = 18/200 = 0.09. Which of the following statements about p-hat as an estimator of p is correct?
- Ap-hat is a biased estimator of p because only 4% of the town's streetlights were sampled.
- BDoubling the sample size to 400 streetlights would make p-hat a less biased estimator of the true proportion p.
- Cp-hat is unbiased for p, so its values center at p over many samples, though 0.09 likely differs from p.Correct
- DBecause the sample was randomly selected, the observed value p-hat = 0.09 must be exactly equal to the true p.
Why C is right
With random sampling, the sample proportion p-hat is an unbiased estimator of the population proportion p: the mean of its sampling distribution equals p. Unbiased describes how the estimator behaves over many repeated samples, not any single sample. So the one observed value, p-hat = 18/200 = 0.09, is subject to sampling variability and will probably not equal p exactly. The sample is 200/5,000 = 4% of the population, which does not bias p-hat.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Wrongly thinks a small sampling fraction causes bias. Bias comes from how a sample is selected, not from what share of the population is sampled. A 4% random sample still gives an unbiased p-hat, and it even meets the 10% condition.
- B
- Mixes up bias with variability. p-hat is already unbiased for a random sample of any size. A larger sample reduces the spread of p-hat (its standard deviation, sqrt(p(1-p)/n), gets smaller), not its bias.
- D
- Confuses unbiased with exact. Random sampling removes systematic bias, but any single p-hat still differs from p because of sampling variability.