In a classic false-belief task, a child watches a character named Sally put a marble in a basket, then leave the room. While Sally is away, Anne moves the marble to a box. When asked where Sally will look for the marble when she returns, a 3-year-old typically says the box. This error indicates the 3-year-old lacks:
- ATransitive inference, because the child cannot reason about relationships between locations
- BConservation, because the child cannot understand that the marble's quantity is unchanged
- CObject permanence, because the child cannot track the marble's location
- DTheory of mind, because the child cannot attribute a false belief to SallyCorrect
Why D is right
Theory of mind is the understanding that other people have beliefs, desires, and intentions that can differ from reality and from your own. Sally did not see Anne move the marble, so she still believes it is in the basket and will look there. The 3-year-old answers 'the box' because that is where the child knows the marble is. The child cannot hold Sally's false belief apart from their own knowledge, which shows an immature theory of mind (D). Children usually start passing this task at around age 4.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Transitive inference is the ability to work out a relationship from linked premises: if A > B and B > C, then A > C. The Sally-Anne task does not ask the child to order or compare anything, so it is not about transitive inference. The child's mistake is giving Sally knowledge she does not have.
- B
- Conservation is the understanding that a quantity stays the same when its appearance changes, such as liquid poured into a taller glass. In this task the marble's quantity never changes. What the child misjudges is another person's mental state.
- C
- The child says the marble is in the box, which is where it really is. That shows the child is tracking its location, so object permanence is intact. The error is about what Sally believes, not about where the object is.