Skip to content
AP Psychology · Social Psychology and Personality

Source credibility

Source credibility appears in 4 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Social Psychology and Personality. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Source credibility is how believable a persuader seems. It rests on two parts: expertise (do they know the topic?) and trustworthiness (are they honest and not trying to gain?).

Why it matters

A credible source usually persuades more at first. In the elaboration likelihood model, source credibility often works as a peripheral cue, swaying people who are not thinking hard about the argument itself.

How the exam tests it

Questions test the sleeper effect, first studied by Carl Hovland. A message from a low-credibility source does little at first, but it can gain impact weeks later because people forget the source and keep the message.

Don’t confuse it with

Students confuse the sleeper effect with the mere exposure effect. Mere exposure means liking something more because you have seen it often, while the sleeper effect is about a message gaining power once its weak source is forgotten.

Source credibility in real questions

Example 1Harder
The 'sleeper effect' in persuasion research refers to the finding that:
  1. APersuasive messages delivered during drowsy states are more effective than those presented when fully alert
  2. BStrong arguments for attitude change require time ('sleeping on it') before they are fully processed and become effective
  3. CRepeated exposure to persuasive messages during sleep consolidates attitude change through memory processes over time
  4. DLow-credibility source messages have little initial effect but may gain impact later as the source is forgottenCorrect

Why D is right

The sleeper effect describes the counterintuitive phenomenon where a persuasive message from a low-credibility source initially fails to produce attitude change (because recipients discount the message due to source credibility concerns), but over time its impact may increase. As people forget who said the message but retain the message content, the discounting cue (low credibility source) dissociates from the message, allowing its persuasive impact to emerge. This is the dissociation cue hypothesis.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the sleeper effect is not about messages delivered during drowsy states; it is about temporal changes in attitude following a low-credibility source message.
B
Incorrect because 'sleeping on' a strong argument describes deliberative processing delay, not the sleeper effect, which specifically involves the temporal dissociation of message content from low-credibility source information.
C
Incorrect because memory consolidation during sleep is a different phenomenon from the social psychology concept of the sleeper effect; the sleeper effect involves forgetting source information, not sleep-based consolidation.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Social Psychology and Personality.