Skip to content
AP Psychology · Development and Learning

Resistance to extinction

Resistance to extinction appears in 9 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Development and Learning. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Resistance to extinction is how long a learned behavior keeps going after reinforcement stops. Behavior learned on partial (intermittent) reinforcement lasts longer than behavior learned on continuous reinforcement, which is the partial reinforcement effect. Variable ratio schedules produce the most resistance of all.

Why it matters

It explains why slot machines and checking your phone are so hard to quit. On a variable ratio schedule, long runs without a reward were already normal, so the learner cannot easily tell that rewards have ended.

How the exam tests it

Stems compare groups trained on different schedules and ask which keeps responding longest after rewards stop. The answer is variable ratio. Continuous reinforcement (FR-1) extinguishes fastest, because the first missing reward is obvious.

Don’t confuse it with

Students confuse it with spontaneous recovery, but spontaneous recovery is a response returning after a rest once extinction has already happened.

Resistance to extinction in real questions

Example 1Medium
A researcher trains pigeons to peck a key for food using continuous reinforcement, then switches to a variable ratio schedule for half the group and a fixed ratio schedule for the other half. When the researcher stops delivering food for all pigeons, which group will most likely continue pecking the longest?
  1. AThe fixed ratio group, because the predictability of the reinforcement schedule makes each food delivery more rewarding and motivating
  2. BBoth groups will extinguish at the same rate, because the total number of reinforcements received determines resistance to extinction equally
  3. CThe variable ratio group, because unpredictable reinforcement makes it harder to detect that reinforcement has stoppedCorrect
  4. DThe continuous reinforcement group, because they received the most total reinforcements, which should build the strongest response tendency

Why C is right

The variable ratio group will show greater resistance to extinction. Under a VR schedule, the pigeon pecks varying numbers of times before food arrives — sometimes 2, sometimes 20. When reinforcement stops during extinction, the VR pigeon cannot easily detect the change, because long response strings without food were already normal. In contrast, FR pigeons pecked predictable numbers before food arrived, so the absence of food is detected sooner. This is the partial reinforcement extinction effect.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because predictability in fixed ratio schedules does not increase resistance to extinction — it actually makes extinction more detectable. The FR pigeon has a clear expectation of when food should arrive and can more easily detect its absence.
B
Incorrect because substantial research demonstrates that VR schedules produce significantly greater resistance to extinction than FR schedules, which produce significantly greater resistance than continuous reinforcement. The schedule type, not total reinforcement count, is the key factor.
D
Incorrect because total reinforcements received do not determine resistance to extinction. Organisms on continuous reinforcement (which maximize reinforcements) actually extinguish fastest because they quickly detect when reinforcement stops, since they expect it after every response.
Example 2Harder
A researcher studying reinforcement schedules compares a fixed ratio 1 schedule (continuous reinforcement, or CRF) with a variable ratio 10 schedule. Which prediction is most consistent with established research on reinforcement schedules?
  1. AThe CRF group will show higher response rates because each response is guaranteed to produce reinforcement
  2. BThe VR-10 group will show higher response rates and greater resistance to extinction than the CRF groupCorrect
  3. CThe CRF group will show greater resistance to extinction because more total reinforcements were received during training
  4. DBoth groups will show identical response rates and resistance to extinction because both schedules produce the same average rate of reinforcement

Why B is right

Variable ratio schedules consistently produce higher response rates and greater resistance to extinction than continuous reinforcement (FR-1). Under VR schedules, organisms respond rapidly because reinforcement is possible after any response, and they cannot predict when it will arrive. During extinction, VR organisms continue responding longer because the absence of reinforcement is indistinguishable from a long run of unreinforced responses (which they experienced during training). CRF organisms, in contrast, quickly detect when reinforcement stops and extinguish rapidly.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the guarantee of reinforcement on every response (CRF) actually produces lower response rates than VR schedules. CRF produces reliable acquisition but not the highest rates. The post-reinforcement pause in CRF (brief rest after each reward) reduces overall rate.
C
Incorrect because total reinforcements received during training does not determine resistance to extinction — the schedule type does. CRF organisms receive a reinforcement for every response and thus receive more total reinforcements for the same number of responses, yet they extinguish fastest. VR organisms extinguish slowest despite receiving fewer total reinforcements.
D
Incorrect because the same average reinforcement rate does not produce identical behavior across different schedule types. The pattern of reinforcement delivery (predictable vs. unpredictable) profoundly affects both response rates and resistance to extinction, independent of overall reinforcement density.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Development and Learning.