While solving multistep algebra problems, Maya silently talks herself through each step ("First isolate x, then divide both sides"). She reports that this inner self-talk helps her reach correct answers. Which explanation of Maya's self-talk is most consistent with a radical behaviorist perspective?
- AHer self-talk is itself a behavior, a private one, that persists because it has been followed by reinforcing consequences such as correct answersCorrect
- BOnly her written work counts as behavior; her private self-talk lies outside scientific study and cannot help explain her problem solving
- CHer self-talk reflects a step-by-step algorithm stored as a mental representation in working memory, which directs her problem solving from within
- DHer self-talk expresses unconscious anxiety about math, which she defends against by narrating each step to herself
Why A is right
Radical behaviorism holds that private events such as thinking, inner speech and feelings are behaviors that happen inside the skin. They follow the same principles of operant conditioning as observable actions. In this problem-solving case (Unit 2, topic 2.2), a radical behaviorist would say Maya's silent self-talk is a covert verbal behavior. It has been strengthened because it was followed by reinforcing consequences: correct answers and finished problems. A methodological behaviorist would instead set private events aside as unobservable. A cognitive psychologist would say a mental algorithm in working memory causes the problem solving, and a psychodynamic theorist would point to unconscious conflict.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- This describes methodological behaviorism, which sets private events aside because they cannot be observed. Radical behaviorism goes further: it treats thinking and inner speech as behavior, explained by the same reinforcement principles as observable actions.
- C
- This is a cognitive explanation. It says internal mental representations (an algorithm held in working memory) cause the problem solving, which is the kind of mentalistic explanation that radical behaviorists reject.
- D
- This is a psychodynamic explanation, which attributes behavior to unconscious conflicts and defenses. Behaviorists of every kind rejected that approach.